Comparing certificates Experimental feature

You are comparing two certificates. By default, only differing attributes are shown. Use the button below to show/hide all attributes.

Showing only differing attributes.
Dell EMC™ Data Domain® 6.0
383-4-424 		TNOR Guard v. 1.1.3
SERTIT-120
name Dell EMC™ Data Domain® 6.0 TNOR Guard v. 1.1.3
category Operating Systems Boundary Protection Devices and Systems
scheme CA NO
status archived active
not_valid_after 20.10.2022 12.05.2027
not_valid_before 20.10.2017 12.05.2022
cert_link https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/epfiles/383-4-424%20CT%20v1.0e.pdf https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/epfiles/SERTIT-120%20C%20v1.0.pdf
report_link https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/epfiles/383-4-424%20CR%20v1.0e.pdf https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/epfiles/SERTIT-120%20CR%20v1.0.pdf
st_link https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/epfiles/DDOS6_EAL2_ST_1.5.pdf https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/epfiles/TNOR%20Guards%20739_20726_aaaa_sc_ed10-4-public.pdf
manufacturer Dell EMC Thales Norway AS
manufacturer_web https://www.dellemc.com/en-ca/index.htm https://www.thales.no/
security_level EAL2+, ALC_FLR.2 EAL4+, AVA_VAN.4, ALC_FLR.3
dgst 4bcaf23e0e27aa66 03972af324dcd07f
heuristics/cert_id 383-4-424 SERTIT-120
heuristics/cpe_matches cpe:2.3:o:dell:emc_data_domain_os:6.0:*:*:*:*:*:*:* {}
heuristics/related_cves CVE-2017-4983, CVE-2023-23692 {}
heuristics/extracted_sars ASE_CCL.1, ATE_FUN.1, ASE_OBJ.2, ALC_CMS.2, ASE_INT.1, ASE_REQ.2, AGD_PRE.1, ATE_IND.2, ASE_ECD.1, AVA_VAN.2, ADV_TDS.1, ALC_FLR.2, ASE_SPD.1, ALC_CMC.2, ADV_FSP.2, ATE_COV.1, AGD_OPE.1, ALC_DEL.1, ASE_TSS.1, ADV_ARC.1 ADV_TDS.3, ALC_FLR.3, ASE_CCL.1, ATE_FUN.1, ASE_OBJ.2, ASE_INT.1, ALC_CMC.4, ASE_REQ.2, AGD_PRE.1, ATE_IND.2, ATE_DPT.1, AVA_VAN.4, ASE_ECD.1, ADV_IMP.1, ALC_LCD.1, ASE_SPD.1, ATE_COV.2, ALC_DVS.1, AGD_OPE.1, ALC_CMS.4, ALC_DEL.1, ASE_TSS.1, ADV_FSP.4, ADV_ARC.1
heuristics/extracted_versions 6.0 1.1.3
heuristics/scheme_data
  • category: Boundary Protection Devices and Systems
  • certification_date: 12.05.2022
  • developer: Thales Norway AS
  • enhanced:
    • category: Boundary Protection Devices and Systems
    • cert_id: SERTIT-120
    • certification_date: 12.05.2022
    • description: TNOR Guard is a technology that provides controlled information flow between networks with different system and application security policies. The TNOR Guard (TOE) is part of the XOmail product family for messaging and information exchange in mission-critical military and civilian networks. The Guard implements high-assurance information flow control for the trusted exchange of information across security domain boundaries. This product is also described in this report as the Target of Evaluation (TOE). The main security feature of the TOE is to mediate a one-way or bidirectional flow between two security domains. The TOE inspects every information object that is requested sent between the security domains, and makes an automated release decision according to configured policy. The TOE covers the following four Guard products: STANAG 4406 Ed 2 Message Guard For connectivity towards the NATO standard Military Message Handling System (MMHS), SMTP Message Guard (E-mail) For connectivity towards standard e-mail systems such as Microsoft Exchange. Supports RFC 6477 for Military Message Handling attributes within the SMTP domain, Chat (XMPP) Guard Instant Messaging service between security domains. XML/SOAP Guard Exchange of XML/SOAP data between security domains.
    • developer: Thales Norway AS
    • documents: frozendict({'cert': [frozendict({'href': 'https://sertit.no/getfile.php/1311036-1656573547/SERTIT/Sertifikater/2022/120/SERTIT-120%20C%20v1.0.pdf'})], 'target': [frozendict({'href': 'https://sertit.no/getfile.php/1310630-1654589563/SERTIT/Sertifikater/2022/120/TNOR%20Guards%20739_20726_aaaa_sc_ed10-4-public.pdf'})], 'report': [frozendict({'href': 'https://sertit.no/getfile.php/1310627-1654589561/SERTIT/Sertifikater/2022/120/SERTIT-120%20CR%20v1.0.pdf'})]})
    • evaluation_facility: System Sikkerhet AS
    • expiration_date: 12.05.2027
    • level: EAL 4, ALC_FLR.3, AVA_VAN.4
    • mutual_recognition: CCRA, SOG-IS
    • product: TNOR Guard version 1.1.3
    • sponsor: Forsvarsmateriell IKT-kapasiteter
  • product: TNOR Guard
  • url: https://sertit.no/certified-products/tnor-guard-article2842-1919.html
maintenance_updates
pdf_data/cert_filename 383-4-424 CT v1.0e.pdf SERTIT-120 C v1.0.pdf
pdf_data/cert_keywords/cc_cert_id
  • CA:
    • 383-4-424: 1
  • NO:
    • SERTIT-120: 2
pdf_data/cert_keywords/cc_security_level
  • EAL:
    • EAL 2: 1
  • EAL:
    • EAL 2: 1
    • EAL 4: 2
    • EAL 4 augmented: 1
pdf_data/cert_keywords/cc_sar
  • ALC:
    • ALC_FLR.2: 1
  • ALC:
    • ALC_FLR: 1
pdf_data/cert_keywords/vendor
  • Thales:
    • Thales: 1
pdf_data/cert_keywords/eval_facility
  • EWA:
    • EWA-Canada: 1
pdf_data/cert_metadata
  • /Author: Shannon, Keith R.
  • /CreationDate: D:20171108114401-05'00'
  • /Creator: Microsoft® Word 2010
  • /ModDate: D:20171108114401-05'00'
  • /Producer: Microsoft® Word 2010
  • pdf_file_size_bytes: 283044
  • pdf_hyperlinks: {}
  • pdf_is_encrypted: False
  • pdf_number_of_pages: 1
  • /Author: helgerudt
  • /CreationDate: D:20220629133919+02'00'
  • /Creator: Hewlett-Packard MFP
  • /ModDate: D:20220629142649+02'00'
  • /Producer: PixEdit AS, PixEdit Version 8.7.4.6
  • /Subject: 201676 201334 VEDLEGG01
  • pdf_file_size_bytes: 1289183
  • pdf_hyperlinks: {}
  • pdf_is_encrypted: False
  • pdf_number_of_pages: 1
pdf_data/report_filename 383-4-424 CR v1.0e.pdf SERTIT-120 CR v1.0.pdf
pdf_data/report_frontpage
  • CA:
  • CA:
pdf_data/report_keywords/cc_cert_id
  • CA:
    • 383-4-424: 1
  • NO:
    • SERTIT-120: 22
pdf_data/report_keywords/cc_security_level
  • EAL:
    • EAL 2: 1
  • EAL:
    • EAL 2: 1
    • EAL 4: 27
    • EAL 4 augmented: 24
pdf_data/report_keywords/cc_sar
  • ALC:
    • ALC_FLR.2: 1
  • ADV:
    • ADV_ARC.1: 1
    • ADV_FSP.4: 1
    • ADV_IMP.1: 1
    • ADV_TDS.3: 1
  • AGD:
    • AGD_OPE.1: 1
    • AGD_PRE.1: 1
  • ALC:
    • ALC_CMC.4: 1
    • ALC_CMS.4: 1
    • ALC_DEL.1: 1
    • ALC_DVS.1: 1
    • ALC_FLR: 1
    • ALC_FLR.3: 26
    • ALC_LCD.1: 1
  • ASE:
    • ASE_CCL.1: 1
    • ASE_ECD.1: 1
    • ASE_INT.1: 1
    • ASE_OBJ.2: 1
    • ASE_REQ.2: 1
    • ASE_SPD.1: 1
    • ASE_TSS.1: 1
  • ATE:
    • ATE_COV.2: 1
    • ATE_DPT.1: 1
    • ATE_FUN.1: 1
    • ATE_IND.2: 1
  • AVA:
    • AVA_VAN.4: 27
pdf_data/report_keywords/vendor
  • Microsoft:
    • Microsoft: 1
  • Thales:
    • Thales: 12
pdf_data/report_keywords/eval_facility
  • EWA:
    • EWA-Canada: 1
pdf_data/report_keywords/crypto_scheme
  • MAC:
    • MAC: 2
  • PKE:
    • PKE: 1
pdf_data/report_keywords/ecc_curve
  • NIST:
    • P-110: 1
pdf_data/report_keywords/standard_id
  • ISO:
    • ISO/IEC 17025:2005: 1
  • CC:
    • CCMB-2017-04-004: 1
  • ISO:
    • ISO/IEC 15408: 8
    • ISO/IEC 17025: 2
    • ISO/IEC 18045: 2
  • RFC:
    • RFC 6477: 1
pdf_data/report_metadata
  • /Author: Shannon, Keith R.
  • /CreationDate: D:20171108115229-05'00'
  • /Creator: Microsoft® Word 2010
  • /ModDate: D:20171108115229-05'00'
  • /Producer: Microsoft® Word 2010
  • /Title: 383-4-XXX CR v0.1
  • pdf_file_size_bytes: 410740
  • pdf_hyperlinks: mailto:[email protected]
  • pdf_is_encrypted: False
  • pdf_number_of_pages: 17
  • /CreationDate: D:20220518100037+02'00'
  • /ModDate: D:20220518100037+02'00'
  • pdf_file_size_bytes: 529073
  • pdf_hyperlinks: {}
  • pdf_is_encrypted: False
  • pdf_number_of_pages: 22
pdf_data/st_filename DDOS6_EAL2_ST_1.5.pdf TNOR Guards 739_20726_aaaa_sc_ed10-4-public.pdf
pdf_data/st_keywords/cc_security_level
  • EAL:
    • EAL 2: 3
    • EAL2+: 1
  • EAL:
    • EAL4: 8
    • EAL4 augmented: 5
pdf_data/st_keywords/cc_sar
  • ADV:
    • ADV_ARC.1: 1
    • ADV_FSP.2: 1
    • ADV_TDS.1: 1
  • AGD:
    • AGD_OPE.1: 1
    • AGD_PRE.1: 1
  • ALC:
    • ALC_CMC.2: 1
    • ALC_CMS.2: 1
    • ALC_DEL.1: 1
    • ALC_FLR.2: 4
  • ASE:
    • ASE_CCL.1: 1
    • ASE_ECD.1: 1
    • ASE_INT.1: 1
    • ASE_OBJ.2: 1
    • ASE_REQ.2: 1
    • ASE_SPD.1: 1
    • ASE_TSS.1: 1
  • ATE:
    • ATE_COV.1: 1
    • ATE_FUN.1: 1
    • ATE_IND.2: 1
  • AVA:
    • AVA_VAN.2: 1
  • ALC:
    • ALC_FLR.3: 6
  • ASE:
    • ASE_CCL: 2
    • ASE_ECD: 2
    • ASE_INT: 2
    • ASE_OBJ: 2
    • ASE_REQ: 2
    • ASE_SPD: 2
    • ASE_TSS: 2
  • AVA:
    • AVA_VAN.4: 6
pdf_data/st_keywords/cc_sfr
  • FAU:
    • FAU_GEN.1: 8
    • FAU_GEN.1.1: 1
    • FAU_GEN.1.2: 1
    • FAU_GEN.2: 7
    • FAU_GEN.2.1: 1
  • FCS:
    • FCS_CKM.1: 13
    • FCS_CKM.1.1: 1
    • FCS_CKM.2: 1
    • FCS_CKM.4: 11
    • FCS_CKM.4.1: 1
    • FCS_COP.1: 10
    • FCS_COP.1.1: 1
  • FDP:
    • FDP_ACC.1: 15
    • FDP_ACC.1.1: 1
    • FDP_ACF.1: 10
    • FDP_ACF.1.1: 1
    • FDP_ACF.1.2: 1
    • FDP_ACF.1.3: 1
    • FDP_ACF.1.4: 1
    • FDP_DDR: 1
    • FDP_DDR_EXT.1: 8
    • FDP_DDR_EXT.1.1: 2
    • FDP_DDR_EXT.1.2: 2
    • FDP_IFC.1: 13
    • FDP_IFC.1.1: 1
    • FDP_IFF.1: 8
    • FDP_IFF.1.1: 1
    • FDP_IFF.1.2: 1
    • FDP_IFF.1.3: 1
    • FDP_IFF.1.4: 1
    • FDP_IFF.1.5: 1
    • FDP_ITC.1: 4
    • FDP_ITC.2: 4
    • FDP_SDI.1: 1
    • FDP_SDI.2: 7
    • FDP_SDI.2.1: 1
    • FDP_SDI.2.2: 1
  • FIA:
    • FIA_UAU.1: 3
    • FIA_UAU.2: 12
    • FIA_UAU.2.1: 1
    • FIA_UAU.7: 7
    • FIA_UAU.7.1: 1
    • FIA_UID.1: 9
    • FIA_UID.2: 14
    • FIA_UID.2.1: 1
  • FMT:
    • FMT_MSA.1: 19
    • FMT_MSA.1.1: 2
    • FMT_MSA.3: 18
    • FMT_MSA.3.1: 2
    • FMT_MSA.3.2: 2
    • FMT_SMF.1: 11
    • FMT_SMF.1.1: 1
    • FMT_SMR.1: 17
    • FMT_SMR.1.1: 1
    • FMT_SMR.1.2: 1
  • FPT:
    • FPT_FLS.1: 7
    • FPT_FLS.1.1: 1
    • FPT_STM.1: 9
    • FPT_STM.1.1: 1
  • FAU:
    • FAU_ARP: 2
    • FAU_ARP.1: 9
    • FAU_GEN: 2
    • FAU_GEN.1: 13
    • FAU_GEN.2: 8
    • FAU_GEN.2.1: 1
    • FAU_SAA: 1
    • FAU_SAA.1: 10
    • FAU_SAR: 1
    • FAU_SAR.1: 11
    • FAU_SAR.2: 8
    • FAU_STG: 1
    • FAU_STG.1: 12
    • FAU_STG.3: 9
    • FAU_STG.4: 9
  • FCO:
    • FCO_NRO: 1
    • FCO_NRO.1: 10
  • FCS:
    • FCS_CKM.1: 2
    • FCS_CKM.4: 1
    • FCS_COP: 1
    • FCS_COP.1: 10
    • FCS_NRO.1: 1
  • FDP:
    • FDP_ACC: 1
    • FDP_ACC.1: 9
    • FDP_ACC.2: 10
    • FDP_ACF: 1
    • FDP_ACF.1: 12
    • FDP_ETC: 1
    • FDP_ETC.2: 13
    • FDP_IFC: 19
    • FDP_IFC.1: 14
    • FDP_IFC.2: 11
    • FDP_IFF: 19
    • FDP_IFF.1: 16
    • FDP_IFF.2: 16
    • FDP_IFF.2.2: 1
    • FDP_ITC: 1
    • FDP_ITC.1: 2
    • FDP_ITC.2: 15
    • FDP_RIP: 1
    • FDP_RIP.1: 1
    • FDP_RIP.2: 10
    • FDP_UIT: 1
    • FDP_UIT.1: 9
  • FIA:
    • FIA_ATD: 1
    • FIA_ATD.1: 9
    • FIA_UID: 1
    • FIA_UID.1: 7
    • FIA_UID.2: 13
  • FMT:
    • FMT_MOF: 19
    • FMT_MOF.1: 5
    • FMT_MSA: 1
    • FMT_MSA.1: 10
    • FMT_MSA.3: 15
    • FMT_MTD: 2
    • FMT_MTD.1: 12
    • FMT_MTD.3: 8
    • FMT_MTS: 1
    • FMT_REV: 1
    • FMT_REV.1: 9
    • FMT_SMF: 1
    • FMT_SMF.1: 15
    • FMT_SMR: 1
    • FMT_SMR.1: 9
    • FMT_SMR.2: 16
    • FMT_TST.1: 1
  • FPT:
    • FPT_FLS: 1
    • FPT_FLS.1: 11
    • FPT_RCV: 1
    • FPT_RCV.4: 10
    • FPT_STM.1: 2
    • FPT_TDC: 1
    • FPT_TDC.1: 11
    • FPT_TST: 1
    • FPT_TST.1: 12
  • FRU:
    • FRU_PRS: 1
    • FRU_PRS.1: 10
  • FTP:
    • FTP_ITC.1: 4
    • FTP_TRP: 1
    • FTP_TRP.1: 15
    • FTP_TRP.2: 2
pdf_data/st_keywords/cc_claims
  • A:
    • A.LOCATE: 3
    • A.MANAGE: 2
    • A.NOEVIL: 3
  • O:
    • O.ACCESS: 11
    • O.ADMIN: 11
    • O.AUDIT: 9
    • O.CRYPTO: 5
    • O.DATAOPT: 7
    • O.IDAUTH: 11
    • O.OBSFEED: 9
    • O.PROTECT: 5
  • OE:
    • OE.ADMIN: 6
    • OE.PHYSICAL: 4
  • T:
    • T.ACCESS: 3
    • T.ACCOUNT: 2
    • T.AUDACC: 3
  • A:
    • A..Z: 1
    • A.APPROVED_CRYPTO: 3
    • A.APPROVED_PKI: 2
    • A.CORRECT_CONFIGURATION: 3
    • A.NETWORK_PROTECTED: 2
    • A.PHYSICAL_ACCESS_MANAGED: 3
    • A.TRUSTED_AND_TRAINED_ADMIN: 2
    • A.TRUSTED_LABELLER: 3
  • O:
    • O.ACCESS: 8
    • O.AUDIT: 13
    • O.CMD_ACL: 10
    • O.CONFIGURATION_CHANGE: 5
    • O.CONTROLLED_INFORMATION: 1
    • O.CONTROLLED_INFORMATION_FLOW: 5
    • O.CORRECT_TSF_OPERATION: 6
    • O.INTERNAL_LEAST_PRIVILEG: 1
    • O.INTERNAL_LEAST_PRIVILEGE: 9
    • O.LABEL_MAPPING: 8
    • O.MAC: 5
    • O.MGMT_MODE: 6
    • O.MINIMAL_PROXY: 10
    • O.OBJECT_INTEGRITY: 9
    • O.RESIDUAL_INFORMATION: 7
    • O.RESOURCE_SHARING: 7
    • O.SECURE_STATE: 8
    • O.SUBJECT_ISOLATION: 12
    • O.TRANSITION: 5
    • O.TSF_INTEGRITY: 9
    • O.VALID_LABEL: 6
  • OE:
    • OE.APPROVED_CRYPTO: 7
    • OE.APPROVED_PKI: 7
    • OE.BORDER_PROTECTION: 12
    • OE.CONFIGURATION: 8
    • OE.CONTENT_INSPECTION_S: 1
    • OE.CONTENT_INSPECTION_SE: 2
    • OE.CONTENT_INSPECTION_SERVICE: 6
    • OE.DIRECTORY_SERVICE: 6
    • OE.MINIMAL_POSTURE: 10
    • OE.NETWORK: 10
    • OE.PHYSICAL_ACCESS_MANA: 2
    • OE.PHYSICAL_ACCESS_MANAG: 1
    • OE.PHYSICAL_ACCESS_MANAGED: 6
    • OE.PLATFORM: 10
    • OE.TIME_SOURCE: 6
    • OE.TRUSTED_AND_TRAINED_: 1
    • OE.TRUSTED_AND_TRAINED_A: 1
    • OE.TRUSTED_AND_TRAINED_ADMIN: 8
    • OE.TRUSTED_AND_TRAINED_ADMINS: 1
    • OE.TRUSTED_LABELLER: 7
  • T:
    • T.ADMIN_MASQUERADE: 4
    • T.AUDIT_COMPROMISE: 2
    • T.COVERT_CHANNEL: 2
    • T.DOS: 4
    • T.INFORMATION_LEAK: 2
    • T.INSECURE_STATE: 4
    • T.MALWARE_INJECTION: 2
    • T.METADATA_LEAK: 4
    • T.NETWORK_ATTACK: 2
    • T.OBJECT_TAMPERING: 4
    • T.RECONNAISSANCE: 4
    • T.RESIDUAL_DATA: 2
    • T.TSF_COMPROMISE: 3
    • T.UNATTENDED_ADMIN_SESSION: 2
    • T.UNAUTHORIZED_ACCESS: 4
    • T.UNNOTICED_ATTACK: 2
pdf_data/st_keywords/vendor
  • Microsoft:
    • Microsoft: 1
  • Thales:
    • Thales: 80
pdf_data/st_keywords/eval_facility
  • EWA:
    • EWA-Canada: 1
pdf_data/st_keywords/symmetric_crypto
  • AES_competition:
    • AES:
      • AES: 3
      • AES-128: 2
      • AES-256: 2
pdf_data/st_keywords/crypto_scheme
  • MAC:
    • MAC: 22
  • PKE:
    • PKE: 1
pdf_data/st_keywords/crypto_protocol
  • SSH:
    • SSH: 1
  • TLS:
    • TLS:
      • TLS: 1
  • SSH:
    • SSH: 3
pdf_data/st_keywords/randomness
  • PRNG:
    • DRBG: 1
pdf_data/st_keywords/cipher_mode
  • CBC:
    • CBC: 4
  • GCM:
    • GCM: 4
pdf_data/st_keywords/standard_id
  • CC:
    • CCMB-2012-09-001: 1
    • CCMB-2012-09-002: 1
    • CCMB-2012-09-003: 1
  • FIPS:
    • FIPS 140-2: 2
    • FIPS 197: 1
  • FIPS:
    • FIPS PUB 180-4: 2
  • ISO:
    • ISO/IEC 15408: 6
  • PKCS:
    • PKCS #11: 2
    • PKCS#11: 4
    • PKCS11: 2
  • RFC:
    • RFC 5321: 1
    • RFC 5322: 1
    • RFC 6120: 1
    • RFC 6121: 1
    • RFC 6477: 1
    • RFC 7622: 2
    • RFC3507: 2
    • RFC5905: 1
    • RFC6120: 2
    • RFC6121: 1
  • X509:
    • X.509: 1
pdf_data/st_metadata
  • /Author: Teresa MacArthur
  • /CC Version: 3.1R4
  • /CC date: September 2012
  • /CEM Version: 3.1R4
  • /CEM date: September 2012
  • /Client City: Hopkinton
  • /Client Country: USA
  • /Client Postal Code: 01748
  • /Client Short Name: EMC
  • /Client State: Massachusetts
  • /Client Street: 176 South Street
  • /Company: EWA-Canada
  • /CreationDate: D:20170828130531-04'00'
  • /Creator: Acrobat PDFMaker 10.1 for Word
  • /EAL Long: 2 Augmented
  • /EAL Short: 2
  • /Eval number: 383-4-tbd
  • /ModDate: D:20170828130539-04'00'
  • /Producer: Adobe PDF Library 10.0
  • /ProjectNumber: 1937
  • /ST_Date: 28 August 2017
  • /ST_Title: Dell EMC™ Data Domain® 6.0
  • /ST_version: 1.5
  • /SourceModified: D:20170828164041
  • /TOE: Data Domain Deduplication Storage Systems
  • /TOE Short: Data Domain
  • /Title: Security Target
  • /client full name: Dell EMC
  • /document number: 2011-000-D102
  • pdf_file_size_bytes: 363924
  • pdf_hyperlinks: {}
  • pdf_is_encrypted: False
  • pdf_number_of_pages: 45
  • /Author: Radical
  • /CreationDate: D:20220510093219+02'00'
  • /Creator: Microsoft® Word 2016
  • /ModDate: D:20220510093219+02'00'
  • /Producer: Microsoft® Word 2016
  • /Title: System/Subsystem Specification
  • pdf_file_size_bytes: 3028038
  • pdf_hyperlinks: {}
  • pdf_is_encrypted: False
  • pdf_number_of_pages: 78
state/cert/pdf_hash Different Different
state/cert/txt_hash Different Different
state/report/pdf_hash Different Different
state/report/txt_hash Different Different
state/st/pdf_hash Different Different
state/st/txt_hash Different Different