Comparing certificates Experimental feature

You are comparing two certificates. By default, only differing attributes are shown. Use the button below to show/hide all attributes.

Showing only differing attributes.
Waterfall Unidirectional Security Gateway model WF-400, version 1
NSCIB-CC-11-34146-CR 		Voyager TDC 10G Switch - V2.0
CCEVS-VR-VID-10911-2018
name Waterfall Unidirectional Security Gateway model WF-400, version 1 Voyager TDC 10G Switch - V2.0
category Boundary Protection Devices and Systems Network and Network-Related Devices and Systems
scheme NL US
not_valid_after 12.07.2022 19.11.2020
not_valid_before 12.07.2012 19.11.2018
cert_link https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/epfiles/PC4603306.pdf https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/epfiles/st_vid10911-ci.pdf
report_link https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/epfiles/Certification%20Report%20NSCIB-CC-11-34146-CR.pdf https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/epfiles/st_vid10911-vr.pdf
st_link https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/epfiles/[ST]%20Waterfall%20Security%20Target%20v0.72.pdf https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/epfiles/st_vid10911-st.pdf
manufacturer Waterfall Security Solutions Ltd. Klas Telecom, Inc.
manufacturer_web https://www.waterfallsecurity.com https://www.klastelecom.com
security_level ALC_FLR.2, ALC_DVS.2, EAL4+, AVA_VAN.5 {}
dgst 8ac1877ab0743d65 6a5bcffadf014b67
heuristics/cert_id NSCIB-CC-11-34146-CR CCEVS-VR-VID-10911-2018
heuristics/cert_lab US
heuristics/extracted_sars ASE_INT.1, ALC_DVS.2, ALC_CMC.4, ASE_ECD.1, ADV_IMP.1, ATE_COV.2, ASE_TSS.1, ALC_TAT.1, ASE_SPD.1, AVA_VAN.5, ALC_DEL.1, ALC_LCD.1, AGD_OPE.1, AGD_PRE.1, ALC_CMS.4, ATE_FUN.1, ADV_ARC.1, ASE_OBJ.2, ADV_TDS.3, ATE_DPT.1, ALC_FLR.2, ASE_REQ.2, ADV_FSP.4, ATE_IND.2, ASE_CCL.1 ASE_TSS.1, ADV_FSP.1, ALC_CMC.1, ASE_INT.1, ASE_SPD.1, ASE_OBJ.1, AVA_VAN.1, ATE_IND.1, ALC_CMS.1, AGD_OPE.1, ASE_REQ.1, ASE_CCL.1, ASE_ECD.1, AGD_PRE.1
heuristics/extracted_versions 1, 400 2.0
heuristics/report_references/directly_referenced_by NSCIB-CC-119023-CR {}
heuristics/report_references/indirectly_referenced_by NSCIB-CC-119023-CR {}
heuristics/scheme_data
  • category: Network Device
  • certification_date: 19.11.2018
  • evaluation_facility: UL Verification Services Inc. (Formerly InfoGard)
  • expiration_date: 19.11.2020
  • id: CCEVS-VR-VID10911
  • product: Voyager TDC 10G Switch - V2.0
  • scheme: US
  • url: https://www.niap-ccevs.org/product/10911
  • vendor: Klas
heuristics/protection_profiles {} 48ac4778e4272298
protection_profile_links {} https://www.commoncriteriaportal.org/nfs/ccpfiles/files/ppfiles/CPP_ND_V2.0E.pdf
pdf_data/cert_filename PC4603306.pdf st_vid10911-ci.pdf
pdf_data/cert_keywords/cc_cert_id
  • NL:
    • NSCIB-CC-11-34146-CR: 1
  • US:
    • CCEVS-VR-VID10911-2018: 1
pdf_data/cert_keywords/cc_security_level
  • EAL:
    • EAL4: 1
    • EAL4 augmented: 1
pdf_data/cert_keywords/cc_sar
  • ALC:
    • ALC_DVS.2: 1
    • ALC_FLR.2: 1
  • AVA:
    • AVA_VAN.5: 1
pdf_data/cert_keywords/eval_facility
  • BrightSight:
    • Brightsight: 1
  • UL:
    • UL Verification Services: 1
pdf_data/cert_keywords/standard_id
  • ISO:
    • ISO/IEC 15408: 2
    • ISO/IEC 18045: 2
pdf_data/cert_metadata
  • /CreationDate: D:20120719133408+01'00'
  • /Creator: SimplifyScan registered to 5002687 (ID:15379591)
  • /Producer: Nuance Communications, Inc.
  • pdf_file_size_bytes: 165830
  • pdf_hyperlinks: {}
  • pdf_is_encrypted: False
  • pdf_number_of_pages: 1
  • /CreationDate: D:20190523144612-04'00'
  • /ModDate: D:20190523144612-04'00'
  • /Producer: iText 2.1.0 (by lowagie.com)
  • pdf_file_size_bytes: 181137
  • pdf_hyperlinks: {}
  • pdf_is_encrypted: False
  • pdf_number_of_pages: 1
pdf_data/report_filename Certification Report NSCIB-CC-11-34146-CR.pdf st_vid10911-vr.pdf
pdf_data/report_frontpage
  • NL:
    • cert_id: NSCIB-CC-11-34146-CR
    • cert_item:
    • cert_lab: Brightsight
    • developer: Waterfall Security Solutions Ltd
  • US:
  • NL:
  • US:
    • cert_id: CCEVS-VID10911-VR-2018
    • cert_item: Klas Telecom, Inc. VoyagerTDC 10G Switch v2.0
    • cert_lab: US NIAP
pdf_data/report_keywords/cc_cert_id
  • NL:
    • NSCIB-CC-11-34146: 1
    • NSCIB-CC-11-34146-CR: 13
pdf_data/report_keywords/cc_security_level
  • EAL:
    • EAL 4: 2
    • EAL 4 augmented: 1
    • EAL4: 5
    • EAL4 augmented: 2
    • EAL4+: 2
pdf_data/report_keywords/cc_sar
  • ADV:
    • ADV_ARC.1: 1
    • ADV_FSP.4: 1
    • ADV_IMP.1: 1
    • ADV_TDS: 1
    • ADV_TDS.3: 1
  • AGD:
    • AGD_OPE.1: 1
    • AGD_PRE.1: 1
  • ALC:
    • ALC_CMC.4: 1
    • ALC_CMS.4: 1
    • ALC_DEL.1: 1
    • ALC_DVS.2: 4
    • ALC_FLR.2: 4
    • ALC_LCD.1: 1
    • ALC_TAT.1: 1
  • ASE:
    • ASE_CCL.1: 1
    • ASE_ECD.1: 1
    • ASE_INT.1: 1
    • ASE_OBJ.2: 1
    • ASE_REQ.2: 1
    • ASE_SPD.1: 1
    • ASE_TSS.1: 1
  • ATE:
    • ATE_COV.2: 1
    • ATE_DPT.1: 1
    • ATE_FUN.1: 1
    • ATE_IND.2: 1
  • AVA:
    • AVA_VAN.5: 4
  • AVA:
    • AVA_VAN: 1
    • AVA_VAN.1: 1
pdf_data/report_keywords/cc_sfr
  • FTP:
    • FTP_ITC.1: 1
pdf_data/report_keywords/cc_claims
  • A:
    • A.ADMIN_CREDENTIALS_SECURE: 1
    • A.LIMITED_FUNCTIONALITY: 1
    • A.NO_THRU_TRAFFIC_PROTECTION: 1
    • A.PHYSICAL_PROTECTION: 1
    • A.REGULAR_UPDATES: 1
    • A.RESIDUAL_INFORMATION: 1
    • A.TRUSTED_ADMINISTRATOR: 1
  • T:
    • T.PASSWORD_CRACKING: 1
    • T.SECURITY_FUNCTIONALITY_COMPROMISE: 1
    • T.SECURITY_FUNCTIONALITY_FAILURE: 1
    • T.UNAUTHORIZED_ADMINISTRATOR_ACCESS: 1
    • T.UNDETECTED_ACTIVITY: 1
    • T.UNTRUSTED_COMMUNICATION_CHANNELS: 1
    • T.UPDATE_COMPROMISE: 1
    • T.WEAK_AUTHENTICATION_ENDPOINTS: 1
    • T.WEAK_CRYPTOGRAPHY: 1
pdf_data/report_keywords/eval_facility
  • BrightSight:
    • Brightsight: 4
  • Lightship:
    • Lightship Security: 7
  • UL:
    • UL Verification Services: 2
pdf_data/report_keywords/symmetric_crypto
  • constructions:
    • MAC:
      • HMAC: 1
pdf_data/report_keywords/asymmetric_crypto
  • ECC:
    • ECDH:
      • ECDH: 2
    • ECDSA:
      • ECDSA: 1
  • FF:
    • DH:
      • DH: 1
      • Diffie-Hellman: 1
pdf_data/report_keywords/hash_function
  • SHA:
    • SHA1:
      • SHA1: 1
pdf_data/report_keywords/crypto_scheme
  • KEX:
    • Key exchange: 1
pdf_data/report_keywords/crypto_protocol
  • IPsec:
    • IPsec: 3
  • SSH:
    • SSH: 14
    • SSHv2: 1
  • TLS:
    • TLS:
      • TLS: 1
  • VPN:
    • VPN: 3
pdf_data/report_keywords/ecc_curve
  • NIST:
    • NIST P-256: 3
    • NIST P-384: 1
    • P-256: 5
    • P-384: 7
pdf_data/report_keywords/crypto_library
  • OpenSSL:
    • OpenSSL: 1
pdf_data/report_keywords/side_channel_analysis
  • SCA:
    • side channels: 1
pdf_data/report_keywords/standard_id
  • ISO:
    • ISO/IEC 15408: 2
    • ISO/IEC 18045: 2
  • CC:
    • CCMB-2012-09-001: 1
    • CCMB-2012-09-002: 1
    • CCMB-2012-09-003: 1
    • CCMB-2012-09-004: 1
  • RFC:
    • RFC 5424: 1
    • RFC 791: 1
    • RFC 792: 1
pdf_data/report_metadata
  • /CreationDate: D:20181120153417-05'00'
  • /ModDate: D:20181120153417-05'00'
  • pdf_file_size_bytes: 836833
  • pdf_hyperlinks: {}
  • pdf_is_encrypted: False
  • pdf_number_of_pages: 18
pdf_data/st_filename [ST] Waterfall Security Target v0.72.pdf st_vid10911-st.pdf
pdf_data/st_keywords/cc_security_level
  • EAL:
    • EAL 4: 3
    • EAL 4 augmented: 1
    • EAL4: 10
    • EAL4 augmented: 1
pdf_data/st_keywords/cc_sar
  • ADV:
    • ADV_ARC.1: 6
    • ADV_FSP.1: 1
    • ADV_FSP.2: 2
    • ADV_FSP.4: 7
    • ADV_IMP.1: 5
    • ADV_TDS.1: 1
    • ADV_TDS.2: 1
    • ADV_TDS.3: 8
  • AGD:
    • AGD_OPE.1: 6
    • AGD_PRE.1: 6
  • ALC:
    • ALC_CMC.4: 2
    • ALC_CMS.4: 2
    • ALC_DEL.1: 2
    • ALC_DVS.1: 2
    • ALC_DVS.2: 10
    • ALC_FLR.2: 7
    • ALC_LCD.1: 4
    • ALC_TAT.1: 4
  • ASE:
    • ASE_CCL.1: 1
    • ASE_ECD.1: 1
    • ASE_INT.1: 1
    • ASE_OBJ.2: 1
    • ASE_REQ.2: 1
    • ASE_SPD.1: 1
    • ASE_TSS.1: 1
  • ATE:
    • ATE_COV.1: 2
    • ATE_COV.2: 3
    • ATE_DPT.1: 4
    • ATE_FUN.1: 8
    • ATE_IND.2: 2
  • AVA:
    • AVA_VAN.5: 8
  • ADV:
    • ADV_FSP.1: 5
  • AGD:
    • AGD_OPE.1: 2
    • AGD_PRE.1: 2
  • ALC:
    • ALC_CMC.1: 3
    • ALC_CMS.1: 3
  • ASE:
    • ASE_CCL.1: 1
    • ASE_ECD.1: 1
    • ASE_INT.1: 1
    • ASE_OBJ.1: 1
    • ASE_REQ.1: 1
    • ASE_SPD.1: 1
    • ASE_TSS.1: 1
  • ATE:
    • ATE_IND: 2
    • ATE_IND.1: 3
  • AVA:
    • AVA_VAN: 2
    • AVA_VAN.1: 2
pdf_data/st_keywords/cc_sfr
  • FDP:
    • FDP_IFC.1: 1
    • FDP_IFC.2: 8
    • FDP_IFC.2.1: 2
    • FDP_IFC.2.2: 1
    • FDP_IFF.1: 9
    • FDP_IFF.1.1: 1
    • FDP_IFF.1.2: 1
    • FDP_IFF.1.3: 1
    • FDP_IFF.1.4: 1
    • FDP_IFF.1.5: 3
  • FMT:
    • FMT_MSA.3: 2
  • FAU:
    • FAU_GEN.1: 5
    • FAU_GEN.1.1: 9
    • FAU_GEN.1.2: 1
    • FAU_GEN.2: 3
    • FAU_GEN.2.1: 1
    • FAU_STG_EXT: 7
    • FAU_STG_EXT.1: 3
    • FAU_STG_EXT.1.1: 2
    • FAU_STG_EXT.1.2: 5
    • FAU_STG_EXT.1.3: 12
  • FCO:
    • FCO_CPC_EXT.1: 1
    • FCO_CPC_EXT.1.2: 1
  • FCS:
    • FCS_CKM.1: 8
    • FCS_CKM.1.1: 7
    • FCS_CKM.2: 5
    • FCS_CKM.2.1: 4
    • FCS_CKM.4: 5
    • FCS_CKM.4.1: 1
    • FCS_COP: 18
    • FCS_COP.1: 13
    • FCS_RBG_EXT: 2
    • FCS_RBG_EXT.1: 4
    • FCS_RBG_EXT.1.1: 1
    • FCS_RBG_EXT.1.2: 3
    • FCS_SSHC_EXT.1: 4
    • FCS_SSHC_EXT.1.1: 1
    • FCS_SSHC_EXT.1.2: 3
    • FCS_SSHC_EXT.1.4: 1
    • FCS_SSHC_EXT.1.5: 5
    • FCS_SSHC_EXT.1.6: 2
    • FCS_SSHC_EXT.1.7: 1
    • FCS_SSHC_EXT.1.8: 2
    • FCS_SSHC_EXT.1.9: 4
    • FCS_SSHC_EXTS.1.1: 1
    • FCS_SSHS_EXT.1: 3
    • FCS_SSHS_EXT.1.1: 2
    • FCS_SSHS_EXT.1.2: 3
    • FCS_SSHS_EXT.1.4: 4
    • FCS_SSHS_EXT.1.5: 4
    • FCS_SSHS_EXT.1.6: 2
    • FCS_SSHS_EXT.1.7: 1
    • FCS_SSHS_EXT.1.8: 2
  • FIA:
    • FIA_AFL.1: 9
    • FIA_AFL.1.1: 2
    • FIA_AFL.1.2: 4
    • FIA_PMG_EXT.1: 4
    • FIA_PMG_EXT.1.1: 1
    • FIA_UAU.1: 1
    • FIA_UAU.1.1: 1
    • FIA_UAU.7: 5
    • FIA_UAU.7.1: 1
    • FIA_UAU_EXT.2: 12
    • FIA_UAU_EXT.2.1: 1
    • FIA_UIA_EXT.1: 16
    • FIA_UIA_EXT.1.1: 2
    • FIA_UIA_EXT.1.2: 2
  • FMT:
    • FMT_MOF: 27
    • FMT_MOF.1: 7
    • FMT_MTD: 7
    • FMT_MTD.1: 11
    • FMT_SMF.1: 8
    • FMT_SMF.1.1: 4
    • FMT_SMR.2: 6
    • FMT_SMR.2.1: 1
    • FMT_SMR.2.2: 2
    • FMT_SMR.2.3: 3
  • FPT:
    • FPT_APW_EXT: 1
    • FPT_APW_EXT.1: 4
    • FPT_APW_EXT.1.1: 1
    • FPT_APW_EXT.1.2: 1
    • FPT_ITT.1: 5
    • FPT_SKP_EXT: 1
    • FPT_SKP_EXT.1: 4
    • FPT_SKP_EXT.1.1: 1
    • FPT_STM_EXT: 1
    • FPT_STM_EXT.1: 4
    • FPT_STM_EXT.1.1: 1
    • FPT_STM_EXT.1.2: 2
    • FPT_TRP: 1
    • FPT_TST_EXT: 1
    • FPT_TST_EXT.1: 4
    • FPT_TST_EXT.1.1: 1
    • FPT_TST_EXT.2: 1
    • FPT_TUD_EXT: 1
    • FPT_TUD_EXT.1: 5
    • FPT_TUD_EXT.1.1: 3
    • FPT_TUD_EXT.1.2: 5
    • FPT_TUD_EXT.1.3: 6
    • FPT_TUD_EXT.2: 1
    • FPT_TUD_EXT.2.2: 2
  • FTA:
    • FTA_SSL.3: 6
    • FTA_SSL.3.1: 1
    • FTA_SSL.4: 4
    • FTA_SSL.4.1: 1
    • FTA_SSL_EXT.1: 6
    • FTA_SSL_EXT.1.1: 1
    • FTA_TAB: 1
    • FTA_TAB.1: 8
    • FTA_TAB.1.1: 1
  • FTP:
    • FTP_ITC.1: 14
    • FTP_ITC.1.1: 3
    • FTP_ITC.1.2: 1
    • FTP_ITC.1.3: 1
    • FTP_ITC_EXT.1: 1
    • FTP_TRP: 6
    • FTP_TRP.1: 5
pdf_data/st_keywords/cc_claims
  • A:
    • A.ADMIN: 3
    • A.NETWORK: 4
    • A.PHYSICAL: 4
  • O:
    • O.UNIDIRECTIONAL: 8
  • OE:
    • OE.FILTER_LOW: 4
  • T:
    • T.HACK_HIGH: 1
    • T.HACK_LOW: 3
    • T.LEAKAGE: 2
  • A:
    • A.ADMIN_CREDENTIALS_SECURE: 1
    • A.LIMITED_FUNCTIONALITY: 1
    • A.NO_THRU_TRAFFIC_PROTECTION: 1
    • A.PHYSICAL_PROTECTION: 1
    • A.REGULAR_UPDATES: 1
    • A.RESIDUAL_INFORMATION: 1
    • A.TRUSTED_ADMINISTRATOR: 1
  • D:
    • D.C: 1
  • OE:
    • OE.ADMIN_CREDENTIALS_SECURE: 1
    • OE.NO_GENERAL_PURPOSE: 1
    • OE.NO_THRU_TRAFFIC_PROTECTION: 1
    • OE.PHYSICAL: 1
    • OE.RESIDUAL_INFORMATION: 1
    • OE.TRUSTED_ADMIN: 1
    • OE.UPDATES: 1
  • T:
    • T.PASSWORD_CRACKING: 1
    • T.SECURITY_FUNCTIONALITY_COMPROMISE: 1
    • T.SECURITY_FUNCTIONALITY_FAILURE: 1
    • T.UNAUTHORIZED_ADMINISTRATOR_ACCESS: 1
    • T.UNDETECTED_ACTIVITY: 1
    • T.UNTRUSTED_COMMUNICATION_CHANNELS: 1
    • T.UPDATE_COMPROMISE: 1
    • T.WEAK_AUTHENTICATION_ENDPOINTS: 1
    • T.WEAK_CRYPTOGRAPHY: 1
pdf_data/st_keywords/eval_facility
  • UL:
    • UL Verification Services: 1
pdf_data/st_keywords/symmetric_crypto
  • AES_competition:
    • AES:
      • AES: 15
  • constructions:
    • MAC:
      • HMAC: 15
      • HMAC-SHA-256: 1
      • HMAC-SHA-512: 1
pdf_data/st_keywords/asymmetric_crypto
  • ECC:
    • ECC:
      • ECC: 8
    • ECDH:
      • ECDH: 7
      • ECDHE: 1
    • ECDSA:
      • ECDSA: 11
  • FF:
    • DH:
      • DH: 6
      • DHE: 1
      • Diffie-Hellman: 11
    • DSA:
      • DSA: 2
  • RSA:
    • RSA-2048: 1
pdf_data/st_keywords/hash_function
  • MD:
    • MD5:
      • MD5: 1
  • SHA:
    • SHA1:
      • SHA-1: 3
      • SHA1: 3
    • SHA2:
      • SHA-2: 1
      • SHA-256: 6
      • SHA-384: 2
      • SHA-512: 2
      • SHA2: 2
pdf_data/st_keywords/crypto_scheme
  • KEX:
    • Key Exchange: 1
    • Key exchange: 1
  • MAC:
    • MAC: 26
pdf_data/st_keywords/crypto_protocol
  • IKE:
    • IKE: 1
  • IPsec:
    • IPsec: 5
  • SSH:
    • SSH: 155
    • SSHv2: 1
  • TLS:
    • TLS:
      • TLS: 4
pdf_data/st_keywords/randomness
  • PRNG:
    • DRBG: 9
  • RNG:
    • RBG: 7
    • RNG: 5
pdf_data/st_keywords/cipher_mode
  • CBC:
    • CBC: 3
  • CTR:
    • CTR: 1
  • GCM:
    • GCM: 7
pdf_data/st_keywords/ecc_curve
  • NIST:
    • NIST P-256: 4
    • NIST P-384: 2
    • P-256: 18
    • P-384: 16
    • P-521: 8
pdf_data/st_keywords/crypto_library
  • OpenSSL:
    • OpenSSL: 8
pdf_data/st_keywords/side_channel_analysis
  • FI:
    • physical tampering: 1
pdf_data/st_keywords/standard_id
  • CC:
    • CCMB-2009-07-002: 1
  • CC:
    • CCMB-2009-07-004: 1
  • FIPS:
    • FIPS 140-2: 2
    • FIPS 186-4: 7
    • FIPS PUB 186-4: 4
  • ISO:
    • ISO/IEC 10118: 2
    • ISO/IEC 14888-3: 2
    • ISO/IEC 18031:2011: 3
    • ISO/IEC 9796-2: 1
  • NIST:
    • NIST SP 800-56A: 1
    • NIST SP 800-56B: 1
    • SP 800-131A: 1
    • SP 800-56A: 1
    • SP 800-56B: 1
  • PKCS:
    • PKCS #1: 1
  • RFC:
    • RFC 3526: 6
    • RFC 4251: 1
    • RFC 4253: 8
    • RFC 5424: 2
    • RFC 5647: 10
    • RFC 6668: 2
pdf_data/st_keywords/certification_process
  • OutOfScope:
    • indicated as “REQUIRED” but not listed in the later elements of this component are implemented is out of scope of the evaluation activity for this requirement. RFC 5647 only applies to the RFC compliant: 2
    • out of scope: 2
pdf_data/st_metadata
  • /Author: Nir Naaman
  • /Company: Waterfall Ltd.
  • /CreationDate: D:20120702152437+02'00'
  • /Creator: Acrobat PDFMaker 7.0.5 for Word
  • /ModDate: D:20120702152447+02'00'
  • /Producer: Acrobat Distiller 7.0.5 (Windows)
  • /Revision: 0.72
  • /Subject: Security Target
  • /TOE: Waterfall Unidirectional Security gateway
  • /TOE_ID: WF-400
  • /TOE_version: 1
  • /Title: Waterfall Unidirectional Security Gateway
  • /documentDate: 29/6/2012
  • /longDate: June 29, 2012
  • pdf_file_size_bytes: 339428
  • pdf_hyperlinks: {}
  • pdf_is_encrypted: False
  • pdf_number_of_pages: 24
  • /Author: Bethany Henderson
  • /Company:
  • /CreationDate: D:20181119065151-08'00'
  • /Creator: Acrobat PDFMaker 19 for Word
  • /ModDate: D:20181119065211-08'00'
  • /Producer: Adobe PDF Library 19.8.103
  • /SourceModified: D:20181119145123
  • pdf_file_size_bytes: 804298
  • pdf_hyperlinks: {}
  • pdf_is_encrypted: False
  • pdf_number_of_pages: 100
state/cert/convert_garbage False True
state/cert/pdf_hash Different Different
state/cert/txt_hash Different Different
state/report/pdf_hash Different Different
state/report/txt_hash Different Different
state/st/pdf_hash Different Different
state/st/txt_hash Different Different