FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 1 of 68
HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024
Router Series
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy
Security Level 1 Validation
Version 1.00
May 2017
Copyright Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P 2017, May be reproduced only in its
original entirety [without revision].
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 2 of 68
Revision Record
Date Revision Version Change Description Author
2017-02-01 1.00 Initial version HPE
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 3 of 68
Table of Contents
1 Introduction.................................................................................................................................... 7
2 Overview......................................................................................................................................... 8
2.1 Comware Router Block Level Diagram................................................................................. 9
2.2 HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series ....................................................................... 12
2.2.1 Product overview...................................................................................................... 12
2.2.2 Test Modules............................................................................................................ 12
3 Security Appliance Validation Level.......................................................................................... 14
4 Physical Characteristics and Security Appliance Interfaces.................................................. 15
4.1 HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series ....................................................................... 15
4.2 Physical Interfaces Mapping ............................................................................................... 15
5 Roles, Services, and Authentication ......................................................................................... 17
5.1 Roles ................................................................................................................................... 17
5.2 Authentication Mechanisms ................................................................................................ 18
6 Services, Key / CSP and Algorithm Tables............................................................................... 20
6.1 Services .............................................................................................................................. 21
6.1.1 Unauthenticated Services ........................................................................................ 34
6.1.2 Non-Approved Services ........................................................................................... 34
6.2 Critical Security Parameters ............................................................................................... 35
6.3 Approved Algorithms........................................................................................................... 48
6.4 Allowed Algorithms.............................................................................................................. 59
6.5 Non-Approved Algorithms................................................................................................... 60
7 Self-Tests...................................................................................................................................... 62
7.1 Power-On Self-Tests........................................................................................................... 62
7.2 Conditional Self-Tests......................................................................................................... 63
8 Delivery and Operation ............................................................................................................... 64
8.1 Secure Delivery................................................................................................................... 64
8.2 Secure Operation................................................................................................................ 64
9 Physical Security Mechanism .................................................................................................... 66
10 Mitigation of Other Attacks....................................................................................................... 67
11 Documentation References ...................................................................................................... 68
11.1 Obtaining documentation .................................................................................................. 68
11.2 Technical support.............................................................................................................. 68
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 4 of 68
TABLE OF TABLES
Table 1 Validation Level by Section......................................................................................................... 14
Table 2 Correspondence between Physical and Logical Interfaces........................................................ 15
Table 3 Roles and Role description ......................................................................................................... 17
Table 4 Crypto Officer Services ............................................................................................................... 22
Table 5 User Services.............................................................................................................................. 30
Table 6 Critical Security Parameters ....................................................................................................... 37
Table 7 Comware V7 Kernel – Approved Algorithms ............................................................................. 50
Table 8 Comware V7 HW Accelerators – Approved Algorithms ............................................................. 52
Table 9 Comware V7 HW Accelerators - Allowed Algorithms ................................................................. 53
Table 10 Comware V7 Firmware – Approved Algorithms....................................................................... 54
Table 11 Comware V7 Firmware - Allowed Algorithms .......................................................................... 59
Table 12 Non-Approved Algorithms........................................................................................................ 60
Table 13 Power-On Self-Tests................................................................................................................. 62
Table 14 Conditional Self-Tests............................................................................................................... 63
TABLE OF FIGURES
Figure 1 Security Architecture Block Diagram ........................................................................................... 9
Figure 2 HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 AC Router (JG406A)................................................................... 12
Figure 3 HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 PoE Router (JG408A) ................................................................. 13
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 5 of 68
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for the HPE
Networking Routers
Keywords: Security Policy, CSP, Roles, Service, Cryptographic Module
List of abbreviations:
Abbreviation Full spelling
AAA Authentication, Authorization, and Accounting
AES Advanced Encryption Standard
CF Compact Flash
CLI Command Line Interface
CMVP Cryptographic Module Validation Program
CSP Critical Security Parameter
DES Data Encryption Standard
DOA Dead on arrival
FCoE Fibre Channel over Ethernet
FIPS Federal Information Processing Standard
HMAC Hash-based Message Authentication Code
HTTP Hyper Text Transfer Protocol
IRF Intelligent Resilient Framework
KAT Known Answer Test
LED Light Emitting Diode
LPU Line Processing Unit
MAC Message Authentication Code
MAN Metropolitan Area Network
MPU Main Processing Unit
NIST National Institute of Standards and Technology
OAA Open Application Architecture
OAP Open Application Platform
PSU Power Supply Unit
RADIUS Remote Authentication Dial In User Service
RAM Random Access Memory
RSA Rivest Shamir and Adleman method for asymmetric encryption
SFP Small Form-Factor Plugable
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 6 of 68
Abbreviation Full spelling
SFP+ Enhanced Small Form-Factor Pluggable
SHA Secure Hash Algorithm
SRPU Switching and routing processor unit
SSL Secure Sockets Layer
XFP 10 Gigabit Small Form-Factor Pluggable
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 7 of 68
1 Introduction
This document is a non-proprietary Cryptographic Module Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork
MSR3024 Router Series. The policy describes how the HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router
Series meet the requirements of FIPS 140-2. This document also describes how to configure
the HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series in FIPS 140-2 mode. This document was
prepared as part of the FIPS 140-2 Security Level 1 validation.
FIPS 140-2 standard details the U.S. Government requirements for cryptographic security
appliances. More information about the standard and validation program is available on the
NIST website at csrc.nist.gov/groups/STM/cmvp/.
This document includes the following sections:
 Overview
 Security Appliance Validation Level
 Physical Characteristics and Security Appliance Interfaces
 Roles, Services and Authentication
 Services, Key / CSP and Algorithm Tables
 Self-Tests
 Delivery and Operation
 Physical Security Mechanism
 Mitigation of Other Attacks
 Obtaining Documentation and Technical Assistance
NOTE: The following names are referencing the same thing: HPE FlexFabric, HPE Networking
devices and HPE Networking Routers.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 8 of 68
2 Overview
The HPE Networking devices are suitable for a range of uses: at the edge of a network,
connecting server clusters in a data center, in an enterprise LAN core, and in large-scale
industrial networks and campus networks. Each device is based on the HPE Comware Software,
Version 7.1.045 platform.
The HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series modules are being validated as a multi-chip
standalone module at FIPS 140-2 Security Level 1.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 9 of 68
2.1 Comware Router Block Level Diagram
Figure 1 Security Architecture Block Diagram
The cryptographic module provides the following services externally:
1. Management: supports various login methods and configuration interfaces for managing the
system.
Cryptographic Module
Hardware
Firmware
Management Service Communication Service
Security Function
Administrator
Network user/IT
entity
Forwarding Function
I1
I2
A2 A3
D2
C2
D1
M1
M2
C1
A1
Authorize
Authorize
Authorize
C3
C4
ACL
Authorize
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 10 of 68
2. Communication: supports interoperation between the communication protocols at different
layers in the protocol stack, such as 802.3, PPP, and IP, and uses the forwarding function to
receive/send packets for the local device and forward packets for other devices.
To ensure security, the security function provides appropriate access control for the cryptographic
module to identify and authenticate the external entities attempting to access them, and authorize
the external entities that pass the identification and authentication. The access control function
also records the external entities’ accesses to the services, such as the beginning time and end
time of a visit. The figure above shows how administrators (crypto officer, user role) and network
users access to a cryptographic module service.
M2: The administrator accesses the management service to configure the security function.
M1: The administrator accesses the management service to configure the communication service.
C1: The security function issues the forwarding control ACL or other control measures to the
forwarding function for security processing like packet filtering.
D2: The communication service uses the forwarding function to receive and send packets for the
local device.
C2: The communication service issues routing entries or MAC address entries to the forwarding
function for forwarding packets for other devices.
A1: The administrator connects to a physical management interface (the console for example) of
the cryptographic module to access the system management access control service of the
security function. If the access succeeds, the l1 access to the management service is authorized.
The security function uses the C3 authorization action to authorize the administrator
administrative roles.
I1: The administrator accesses the management service through the physical management
interface.
A2: The administrator connects to a network interface (such as an Ethernet interface) of the
cryptographic module to access the system management access control service of the security
function. If the access succeeds, the I2 access to the management service is authorized.
I2: The administrator accesses the management service through the network interface.
A3: A network user connects to a network interface of the cryptographic module to access the
communication access control service of the security function. If the access succeeds, D1/D2 are
authorized. The security function uses the C4 authorization action to authorize the network user
the communication service access privilege, namely, the network access privilege.
D1: Forwarding packets for the network user.
To facilitate cryptographic module management, the administrator is allowed to access the
system management service by remote login through a network interface. To prevent the
authentication data of the administrator (such as the username and password) from being
intercepted and prevent the operation commands from being tampered, the cryptographic module
provides the SSH2/HTTPS for secure remote management.
For the management service, the cryptographic module defines predefined roles and custom user
roles, which service differs as result of different access permissions.
Each user can switch to a different user role without reconnecting to the device. To switch to a
different user role, a user must provide the role switching authentication information. The
authentication is identity based. All users can be authenticated locally, and optionally supports
authentication via a RADIUS and TACACS+ server.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 11 of 68
If needed, IPsec can be configured to protect the network data.
No external programs can take control of the cryptographic module, because the cryptographic
module does not provide the general-purpose computing service. This ensures the absolute
control of the cryptographic module.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 12 of 68
2.2 HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
2.2.1 Product overview
The HPE MSR3000 Router Series, the next generation of router from Hewlett Packard
Enterprise (HPE), is a component of the HPE FlexBranch solution, which is a part of the
comprehensive HPE FlexNetwork architecture. These routers feature a modular design that
delivers unmatched application services for medium- to large-sized branch offices. This gives
your IT personnel the benefit of reduced complexity, and simplified configuration, deployment,
and management. The MSR3000 routers use the latest multicore CPUs, offer Gigabit switching,
provide an enhanced PCI bus, and ship with the latest version of HPE Comware software to
help enable high performance with concurrent services.
The MSR3000 series provides a full-featured, resilient routing platform, including IPv6 and
Multi-Protocols Label Switching (MPLS), with up to 5 Mpps forwarding capacity and 3.3 Gb/s of
IPsec VPN encrypted throughput. These routers also support HPE Open Application Platform
(OAP) modules to deliver integrated industry-leading HPE AllianceOne partner applications
such as virtualization, unified communications and collaboration (UC&C), and application
optimization capabilities.
The MSR3000 series provides an agile, flexible network infrastructure that enables you to
quickly adapt to changing business requirements while delivering integrated concurrent services
on a single, easy-to-manage platform. A summary of the highlights of the HPE FlexNetwork
MSR3024 Router Series:
 Up to 5 Mpps forwarding performance; support for multiple concurrent services
 HPE Open Application Platform (OAP) for HPE AllianceOne applications
 Embedded security features with hardware-based encryption, network address translation
(NAT), and virtual private networks (VPNs)
 No additional licensing complexity; no cost for advanced features
 Zero-touch solution, with single-pane-of-glass management
 Power over Ethernet (PoE)
1
2.2.2 Test Modules
Testing included two models in the HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
 HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 AC Router (JG406A)
 HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 PoE Router (JG408A)
Figure 2 HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 AC Router (JG406A)
1
JG408A only
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 13 of 68
Figure 3 HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 PoE Router (JG408A)
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 14 of 68
3 Security Appliance Validation Level
The following table lists the level of validation for each area in the FIPS PUB 140-2.
Table 1 Validation Level by Section
No. Area Level
1 Cryptographic Module Specification 1
2 Cryptographic Module Ports and Interfaces 1
3 Roles, Services, and Authentication 3
4 Finite State Model 1
5 Physical Security 1
6 Operational Environment N/A
7 Cryptographic Key management 1
8 Electromagnetic Interface/Electromagnetic Compatibility 1
9 Self-Tests 1
10 Design Assurance 2
11 Mitigation of Other Attacks N/A
12 Overall Level 1
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 15 of 68
4 Physical Characteristics and Security Appliance
Interfaces
4.1 HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
The HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router series is a multi-chip standalone security appliance,
and the cryptographic boundary is defined as encompassing the “top,” “front,” “left,” “right,”
“bottom,” and “rear” surfaces of the case. The general components of the HPE FlexNetwork
MSR3024 Router series include firmware and hardware, which are placed in the three-
dimensional space within the case.
The HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router provides:
 2 HMIM slots
 4 SIC slots, or 2 DSIC slots, or a combination
 3 RJ-45 1000BASE-T ports (IEEE 802.3ab Type 1000BASE-T)
 1 SFP fixed Gigabit Ethernet SFP port
 LEDs for system, power, and module status.
 Power switch
 Reset switch
The documents on HPE website
(http://h20565.www2.hpe.com/portal/site/hpsc/public/psi/home/?sp4ts.oid=5408895&ac.admitte
d=1470924040301.125225703.1851288163#manuals) describe the ports in detail along with
the interpretation of the LEDs.
4.2 Physical Interfaces Mapping
The physical interfaces provided by the HPE Networking products map to four FIPS 140-2
defined logical interface: data input, data output, control input and status output. Table 2
presents the mapping.
Table 2 Correspondence between Physical and Logical Interfaces
Physical Interface FIPS 140-2 Logical Interface
Networking ports Data Input Interface
Console port
Management Ethernet port
CF card slot
USB ports
Networking ports Data Output Interface
Console port
Management Ethernet port
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 16 of 68
Physical Interface FIPS 140-2 Logical Interface
CF card slot
USB ports
Networking ports Control Input Interface
Console port
Management Ethernet port
Power switches
Reset Switch
Port status LED mode switching button
Networking ports Status Output Interface
Console port
Management Ethernet port
LEDs
Power Slot Power Interface
Backplane
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 17 of 68
5 Roles, Services, and Authentication
5.1 Roles
The HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series provides 18 predefined roles and 64 custom
user roles. There are 16 roles (0) in the device that operators may assume:
 network-admin, level-15, level-9 and security-audit which are the FIPS Crypto-Officer Role,
 network-operator, level 0 ~ level 8, level 10 ~ level 14 and 64 custom user roles which are
defined as the FIPS User Role.
Table 3 presents the roles and roles description. The devices allow multiple management users
to operate the appliance simultaneously.
The HPE Networking routers do not employ a maintenance interface and do not have a
maintenance role.
Table 3 Roles and Role description
FIPS Role Comware Role
Name
Role Description
Crypto-Officer network-admin  Accesses all features and resources in the system, except
for the display security-logfile summary, info-center
security-logfile directory, and security-logfile save
commands.
level-15 Has the same rights as network-admin
Level-9 Has access to all features and resources except those in the
following list.
 RBAC non-debugging commands.
 Local users.
 File management.
 Device management.
 The display history-command all command.
security-audit Security log manager. The user role has the following access to
security log files:
 Access to the commands for displaying and maintaining
security log files (for example, the dir, display security-logfile
summary, and more commands).
 Access to the commands for managing security log files and
security log file system (for example, the info-center
security-logfile directory, mkdir, and security-logfile save
commands).
Only the security-audit user role has access to security log files.
User network-operator  Accesses the display commands for all features and
resources in the system, except for commands such as
display history-command all and display security-logfile
summary.
 Enables local authentication login users to change their own
password.
level-0 Has access to diagnostic commands, including ping, tracert,
and ssh2.
level-1 Has access to the display commands of all features and
resources in the system except display history-command all.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 18 of 68
The level-1 user role also has all access rights of the user role
level-0.
custom user
role;
level-2 to level-8;
level-10 to level-
14
Have no access rights by default. Access rights are
configurable.
5.2 Authentication Mechanisms
HPE networking devices support identity-based authentication, and role-based access control.
 Identity-based authentication
Each user is authenticated upon initial access to the device. The authentication is identity-
based. All users can be authenticated locally, and optionally supports authentication via a
RADIUS and TACACS+ server.
To logon to the appliances, an operator must connect to it through one of the management
interfaces (console port, SSH) and provide a password.
A user must be authenticated using usernames and passwords. The minimum password
length is 15 characters, and the maximum is 63. The passwords must contain at least one
lower case letter (26), one upper case letter (26), one special character (32) and one
numeric character (10). The remaining eleven characters can be a lower case letter (26), an
upper case letter (26), a special character (32) and/or a numeric character (10) equaling 94
possibilities per character. Therefore, for a 15 characters password, the probability of
randomly guessing the correct sequence is 1 in 3.16228xE^29
2
(this calculation is based on
the use of the typical standard American QWERTY computer keyboard).
In order to guess the password in 1 minute with close to probability 1 requires 3.16228xE^29
trials, which is stronger than the one in a million chance required by FIPS 140-2. By default,
the maximum number of consecutive failed login attempts is three and a user failing to log in
after the specified number of attempts must wait for one minute before trying again. Using
Anderson’s formula to calculate the probability of guessing a password in 1 minute:
 P probability of guessing a password in specified period of time
 G number of guesses tested in 1 time unit
 T number of time units
 N number of possible passwords
Then P >= T x G / N (9.48682E-30 = 1 x 3 / 3.16228xE^29)
The probability of guessing a password in 1 minute is 9.48682E-30.
2
Calculation is: 94^15 (total combinations of alpha, numeric, and special characters) - 68^15 (combinations with no
uppercase letters) - 68^15 (combinations with no lowercase letters) - 84^15 (combinations with no numbers) - 62^15
(combinations with no special characters) + 42^15 (combinations with no uppercase letters and no lowercase letters) +
60^15 (combinations with no uppercase letters and no numbers) + 36^15 (combinations with no uppercase letters and
no special characters) + 60^15 (combinations with no lowercase letters and no numbers) + 36^15 (combinations with no
lowercase letters and no special characters) + 52^15 (combinations with no numbers and no special characters) - 24^15
(combinations with only uppercase letters) - 24^15 (combinations with only lowercase letters) - 10^15 (combinations
with only numbers) - 32^15 (combinations with only special characters) ≈ 3.16228xE^29
Calculation without text:
94^15 - 68^15 - 68^15 - 84^15 - 62^15 + 42^15 + 60^15 + 36^15 + 60^15 + 36^15 + 52^15 - 24^15 - 24^15 - 10^15 -
32^15 ≈ 3.16228xE^29
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 19 of 68
To provide additional password security, Comware 7.1 provides additional limits to the
number of consecutive failed login attempts. If an FTP or VTY user fails authentication, the
system adds the user to a password control blacklist. If a user fails to provide the correct
password after the specified number of consecutive attempts, the system can take one of
the following actions, based on the administrator’s choice:
Blocks the user's login attempts until the user is manually removed from the
password control blacklist.
Blocks the user's login attempts within a configurable period of time, and allows the
user to log in again after the period of time elapses or the user is removed from the
password control blacklist.
HPE Networking devices can also use certificate credentials using 2048 bit RSA keys and
SHA-256; in such a case the security strength is 112 bits, so an attacker would have a 1 in
2^112 chance of a successful authentication which is much stronger than the one in a million
chance required by FIPS 140-2. Certificate credentials using ECDSA keys with curves
(P224, P-256, P-384, or P-521) and SHA algorithms (SHA-224, SHA-256, SHA-384, or
SHA-512) are also available and provide a minimum of 112 bits security.
The users who try to log in or switch to a different user privilege level can be authenticated
by RADIUS and TACACS+ Server. The minimum password length is 15 characters, and the
maximum is 63. Therefore, for a 15 characters password, the probability of randomly
guessing the correct sequence is one in 3.16228xE^29. The device (RADIUS client) and the
RADIUS server use a shared key to authenticate RADIUS packets and encrypt user
passwords exchanged between them. For more details, see RFC 2865: 3 Packet Format
Authenticator field and 5.2 User-password.
 Role-based access control
In HPE Comware 7.1.045, the command and resource access permissions are assigned to
roles.
Users are given permission to access a set of commands and resources based on the users'
user roles. Each user can have one or more roles. The user may alternate between
authorized roles after first authenticating to the module.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 20 of 68
6 Services, Key / CSP and Algorithm Tables
Assumptions, Assertions and Caveats
1. The preferred approach is to link Services to Keys/CSPs, Keys/CSPs to Algorithms and Algorithms to Services. When linkage is completed, there is a continuous loop among the
three tables.
2. For linking the tables together, the goals are:
 Confirm every Algorithm is listed at least once by a service.
 Provide a direct mapping of the algorithm to each service that uses it.
 Confirm every CSP is listed at least once by a service
 Provide a direct mapping of the service to each CSP that it uses.
 Provide a quick and easy way for the reviewer to navigate among the tables.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 21 of 68
6.1 Services
Assumptions, Assertions and Caveats
1. The services table is the main focus of the validation. Preferably, it should be listed before the CSP and Algorithm tables.
2. Each service should map to the Key(s) / CSP(s) used by the service. It is not required that each service map to a Key / CSP.
3. Each service should be uniquely identifiable so the entries in the Algorithm Table can easily map to a service.
Services Table Column Definitions
1. Description
Objective of this column is to provide a brief description of the service.
 This column shall include a description of the service.
 Where applicable the service description should describe the action being taken.
2. Input
Objective of this column is to list the input to the service.
 List the type of input such as command, configuration data or output of another service.
3. Output
Objective of this column is to list the output of the service.
 List the type of output generated by the service.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 22 of 68
4. CSP Access
Objective of this column is to provide additional information about the CSP utilized by the service.
 Where applicable this column shall include the unique CSP identifier.
 The CSP identifier should contain a hyperlink to the entry in the CSP table.
5. Available to role
Objective of this column is to identify the role that can utilize the service.
 This column shall include the name of the role that can utilize the service.
Table 4 Crypto Officer Services
Description Input Output CSP Access Available to Role
View Device Status
1. View currently running image version Commands Status of devices None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
2. View installed hardware components
status and version
Commands Status of devices None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
View Running Status
3. View memory status, packet statistics,
interface status, current running image
version, current configuration, routing
table, active sessions, temperature and
SNMP MIB statistics.
Commands
Status of device
functions
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 23 of 68
Perform Network Functions
4. Network diagnostic service such as “ping” Commands
Status of
commands
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
5. Network connection service such as
“SSHv2” client
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP1-1 RSA Public key (read)
CSP1-2 DSA Public key (read)
CSP1-3 ECDSA Public key (read)
CSP2-1 IPsec authentication keys
(read/write/delete)
CSP2-2 IPsec encryption keys (read/write/delete)
CSP2-3 IPsec authentication keys (read)
CSP2-4 IPsec encryption keys (read)
CSP3-1 IKE pre-shared keys (read)
CSP3-2 IKE RSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP3-3 IKE DSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP3-4 IKE Authentication key
(read/write/delete)
CSP3-5 IKE Encryption Key (read/write/delete)
CSP3-6 IKE Diffie-Hellman Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP3-7 IKE Diffie-Hellman Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-1 IKEv2 pre-shared keys (read)
CSP4-2 IKEv2 RSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP4-3 IKEv2 DSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP4-4 IKEv2 ECDSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP4-5 IKEv2 Authentication key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-6 IKEv2 Encryption Key (read/write/delete)
CSP4-7 IKEv2 Diffie-Hellman Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-8 IKEv2 Diffie-Hellman Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-9 IKEv2 ECDH Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-10 IKEv2 ECDH Private Key
(read/write/delete)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 24 of 68
CSP5-1 SSH RSA Private key (read)
CSP5-2 SSH ECDSA Private key (read)
CSP5-3 SSH Diffie-Hellman Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-4 SSH Diffie-Hellman Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-5 SSH ECDH Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-6 SSH ECDH Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-7 SSH Session encryption Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-8 SSH Session authentication Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP9-1 SNMPv3 Authentication Key (read)
CSP9-2 SNMPv3 Encryption Key (read)
CSP7-1 DRBG entropy input (read/write/delete)
CSP8-1 DRBG seed (read/write/delete)
CSP8-2 DRBG V (read/write/delete)
CSP8-3 DRBG Key (read/write/delete)
6. Provide SSHv2 service.
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP1-1 RSA Public key (read)
CSP1-3 ECDSA Public key (read)
CSP5-1 SSH RSA Private key (read)
CSP5-2 SSH ECDSA Private key (read)
CSP5-3 SSH Diffie-Hellman Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-4 SSH Diffie-Hellman Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-5 SSH ECDH Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-6 SSH ECDH Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-7 SSH Session encryption Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-8 SSH Session authentication Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP6-1 User Passwords (read/write/delete)
CSP6-3 RADIUS shared secret keys (read)
CSP6-4 TACACS+ shared secret keys (read)
CSP7-1 DRBG entropy input (read/write/delete)
CSP8-1 DRBG seed (read/write/delete)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 25 of 68
CSP8-2 DRBG V (read/write/delete)
CSP8-3 DRBG Key (read/write/delete)
7. Provide IKEv1/IKEv2/IPsec service to
protect the session between the router
and external server(e.g. Radius
Server/Log Server)
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP1-1 RSA Public key (read)
CSP1-2 DSA Public key (read)
CSP1-3 ECDSA Public key (read)
CSP2-1 IPsec authentication keys
(read/write/delete)
CSP2-2 IPsec encryption keys (read/write/delete)
CSP2-3 IPsec authentication keys (read)
CSP2-4 IPsec encryption keys (read)
CSP3-1 IKE pre-shared keys (read)
CSP3-2 IKE RSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP3-3 IKE DSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP3-4 IKE Authentication key
(read/write/delete)
CSP3-5 IKE Encryption Key (read/write/delete)
CSP3-6 IKE Diffie-Hellman Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP3-7 IKE Diffie-Hellman Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-1 IKEv2 pre-shared keys (read)
CSP4-2 IKEv2 RSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP4-3 IKEv2 DSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP4-4 IKEv2 ECDSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP4-5 IKEv2 Authentication key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-6 IKEv2 Encryption Key (read/write/delete)
CSP4-7 IKEv2 Diffie-Hellman Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-8 IKEv2 Diffie-Hellman Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-9 IKEv2 ECDH Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-10 IKEv2 ECDH Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP7-1 DRBG entropy input (read/write/delete)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 26 of 68
CSP8-1 DRBG seed (read/write/delete)
CSP8-2 DRBG V (read/write/delete)
CSP8-3 DRBG Key (read/write/delete)
8. Provide SNMPv3 service.
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP9-1 SNMPv3 Authentication Key (read)
CSP9-2 SNMPv3 Encryption Key (read)
CSP7-1 DRBG entropy input (delete)
CSP8-1 DRBG seed (delete)
CSP8-2 DRBG V (delete)
CSP8-3 DRBG Key (delete)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
9. Initial Configuration setup (IP, hostname,
DNS server)
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
10. Change the role
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP6-1 User Passwords (read)
CSP6-2 Super password (read)
CSP6-3 RADIUS shared secret keys (read)
CSP6-4 TACACS+ shared secret keys (read)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
11. Reset and change the password of
same/lower privilege user
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP6-1 User Passwords (write/delete)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
12. Maintenance of the super password
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP6-2 Super password (write/delete)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
13. Maintenance (create, destroy, import,
export) of public key/private key/shared
key
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP1-1 RSA Public key (read/write/delete)
CSP1-2 DSA Public key (read/write/delete)
CSP1-3 ECDSA Public key (read/write/delete)
CSP2-3 IPsec authentication keys
(read/write/delete)
CSP2-4 IPsec encryption keys (read/write/delete)
CSP3-1 IKE pre-shared keys (read/write/delete)
CSP3-2 IKE RSA Authentication private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP3-3 IKE DSA Authentication private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-1 IKEv2 pre-shared keys
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-2 IKEv2 RSA Authentication private Key
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 27 of 68
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-3 IKEv2 DSA Authentication private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-4 IKEv2 ECDSA Authentication private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-1 SSH RSA Private key (read/write/delete)
CSP5-2 SSH ECDSA Private key
(read/write/delete)
CSP9-1 SNMPv3 Authentication Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP9-2 SNMPv3 Encryption Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP7-1 DRBG entropy input (read/write/delete)
CSP8-1 DRBG seed (read/write/delete)
CSP8-2 DRBG V (read/write/delete)
CSP8-3 DRBG Key (read/write/delete)
14. Management (create, delete, modify) of
the user roles
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
15. Management of the access control rules
for each role
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
16. Management (create, delete, modify) of
the user account
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP6-1 User Passwords (read/write/delete)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
17. Management of the time
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
18. Maintenance (delete, modify) system
start-up parameters
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
19. File operation (e.g. dir, copy, del)
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP11-1 Firmware Signature (write/delete)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
20. Shut down or Reboot the security
appliance
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP2-1 IPsec authentication keys (delete)
CSP2-2 IPsec encryption keys (delete)
CSP3-4 IKE Authentication key (delete)
CSP3-5 IKE Encryption Key (delete)
CSP4-5 IKEv2 Authentication key (delete)
CSP4-6 IKEv2 Encryption Key (delete)
CSP4-7 IKEv2 Diffie-Hellman Public Key (delete)
CSP4-8 IKEv2 Diffie-Hellman Private Key (delete)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 28 of 68
CSP4-9 IKEv2 ECDH Public Key (delete)
CSP4-10 IKEv2 ECDH Private Key (delete)
CSP5-3 SSH Diffie-Hellman Public Key (delete)
CSP5-4 SSH Diffie-Hellman Private Key (delete)
CSP5-5 SSH ECDH Public Key (delete)
CSP5-6 SSH ECDH Private Key (delete)
CSP5-7 SSH Session encryption Key (delete)
CSP5-8 SSH Session authentication Key (delete)
CSP7-1 DRBG entropy input (delete)
CSP8-1 DRBG seed (delete)
CSP8-2 DRBG V (delete)
CSP8-3 DRBG Key (delete)
CSP11-1 Firmware Signature (read)
21. Maintenance of IKEv1/IKEv2/IPsec.
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP1-1 RSA Public key (read/write/delete)
CSP1-2 DSA Public key (read/write/delete)
CSP1-3 ECDSA Public key (read/write/delete)
CSP2-3 IPsec authentication keys
(read/write/delete)
CSP2-4 IPsec encryption keys (read/write/delete)
CSP3-1 IKE pre-shared keys (read/write/delete)
CSP3-2 IKE RSA Authentication private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP3-3 IKE DSA Authentication private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-1 IKEv2 pre-shared keys
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-2 IKEv2 RSA Authentication private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-3 IKEv2 DSA Authentication private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-4 IKEv2 ECDSA Authentication private Key
(read/write/delete)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
22. Maintenance of SNMPv3
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP9-1 SNMPv3 Authentication Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP9-2 SNMPv3 Encryption Key
(read/write/delete)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
23. Maintenance of SSHv2
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP1-1 RSA Public key (read/write/delete)
CSP1-3 ECDSA Public key (read/write/delete)
CSP5-1 SSH RSA Private key (read/write/delete)
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 29 of 68
CSP5-2 SSH ECDSA Private key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-7 SSH Session encryption Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-8 SSH Session authentication Key
(read/write/delete)
24. Perform self-test
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
25. Displaying and maintaining security log
files
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None security-audit
Perform Configuration Functions
26. Save configuration
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
27. Management of information center
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
28. Define network interfaces and settings
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
29. Set the protocols the routers will
support(e.g. SFTP server, SSHv2 server)
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
30. Enable interfaces and network services
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
31. Management of access control scheme
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Network-admin,
level-15,
level-9
32. Config managing security log files and
security log file system
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None security-audit
33. Enable/Disable FIPS mode of operation
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
All private and session keys are zeroized when
switching between FIPS and non-FIPS modes
Network-admin,
level-15
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 30 of 68
34. Load firmware
3
Commands and
configuration
data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP11-1 Firmware Signature (read)
Network-admin,
level-15
Table 5 User Services
Description Input Output CSP Access Available to Role
View Device Status
1. View currently running image version;
2. View installed hardware components status
and version
Commands Status of devices None
network-operator
level-1
View Running Status
3. View memory status, packet statistics,
interface status, current running image
version, current configuration, routing table,
active sessions, temperature and SNMP MIB
statistics.
Commands
Status of device
functions
None
network-operator
level-1
Perform Network Functions
4. Network diagnostic service such as “ping”;
Commands and
configuration data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
None
Level-0,
Level-1
5. Network connection service such as
“SSHv2” client.
Commands and
configuration data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP1-1 RSA Public key (read)
CSP1-2 DSA Public key (read)
CSP1-3 ECDSA Public key (read)
CSP2-1 IPsec authentication keys
(read/write/delete)
CSP2-2 IPsec encryption keys (read/write/delete)
CSP2-3 IPsec authentication keys (read)
Level-0,
Level-1
3
New firmware versions within the scope of this validation must be validated through the FIPS 140-2 CMVP. Any other firmware loaded into this module is out of the scope of this validation and
requires a separate FIPS 140-2 validation.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 31 of 68
Description Input Output CSP Access Available to Role
CSP2-4 IPsec encryption keys (read)
CSP3-1 IKE pre-shared keys (read)
CSP3-2 IKE RSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP3-3 IKE DSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP3-4 IKE Authentication key (read/write/delete)
CSP3-5 IKE Encryption Key (read/write/delete)
CSP3-6 IKE Diffie-Hellman Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP3-7 IKE Diffie-Hellman Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-1 IKEv2 pre-shared keys (read)
CSP4-2 IKEv2 RSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP4-3 IKEv2 DSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP4-4 IKEv2 ECDSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP4-5 IKEv2 Authentication key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-6 IKEv2 Encryption Key (read/write/delete)
CSP4-7 IKEv2 Diffie-Hellman Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-8 IKEv2 Diffie-Hellman Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-9 IKEv2 ECDH Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-10 IKEv2 ECDH Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-1 SSH RSA Private key (read)
CSP5-2 SSH ECDSA Private key (read)
CSP5-3 SSH Diffie-Hellman Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-4 SSH Diffie-Hellman Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-5 SSH ECDH Public Key (read/write/delete)
CSP5-6 SSH ECDH Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-7 SSH Session encryption Key
(read/write/delete)
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 32 of 68
Description Input Output CSP Access Available to Role
CSP5-8 SSH Session authentication Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP9-1 SNMPv3 Authentication Key (read)
CSP9-2 SNMPv3 Encryption Key (read)
CSP7-1 DRBG entropy input (delete)
CSP8-1 DRBG seed (delete)
CSP8-2 DRBG V (delete)
CSP8-3 DRBG Key (delete)
6. Provide SSHv2 service.
Commands and
configuration data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP1-1 RSA Public key (read)
CSP1-3 ECDSA Public key (read)
CSP5-1 SSH RSA Private key (read)
CSP5-2 SSH ECDSA Private key (read)
CSP5-3 SSH Diffie-Hellman Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-4 SSH Diffie-Hellman Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-5 SSH ECDH Public Key (read/write/delete)
CSP5-6 SSH ECDH Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-7 SSH Session encryption Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP5-8 SSH Session authentication Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP6-1 User Passwords (read/write/delete)
CSP6-3 RADIUS shared secret keys (read)
CSP6-4 TACACS+ shared secret keys (read)
CSP7-1 DRBG entropy input (delete)
CSP8-1 DRBG seed (delete)
CSP8-2 DRBG V (delete)
CSP8-3 DRBG Key (delete)
Level-0,
Level-1
7. Provide IKEv1/IKEv2/IPsec service to protect
the session between the router and external
server(e.g. Radius Server/Log Server)
Commands and
configuration data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP1-1 RSA Public key (read)
CSP1-2 DSA Public key (read)
CSP1-3 ECDSA Public key (read)
CSP2-1 IPsec authentication keys
(read/write/delete)
CSP2-2 IPsec encryption keys (read/write/delete)
CSP2-3 IPsec authentication keys (read)
CSP2-4 IPsec encryption keys (read)
CSP3-1 IKE pre-shared keys (read)
Level-0,
Level-1
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 33 of 68
Description Input Output CSP Access Available to Role
CSP3-2 IKE RSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP3-3 IKE DSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP3-4 IKE Authentication key (read/write/delete)
CSP3-5 IKE Encryption Key (read/write/delete)
CSP3-6 IKE Diffie-Hellman Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP3-7 IKE Diffie-Hellman Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-1 IKEv2 pre-shared keys (read)
CSP4-2 IKEv2 RSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP4-3 IKEv2 DSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP4-4 IKEv2 ECDSA Authentication private Key
(read)
CSP4-5 IKEv2 Authentication key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-6 IKEv2 Encryption Key (read/write/delete)
CSP4-7 IKEv2 Diffie-Hellman Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-8 IKEv2 Diffie-Hellman Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-9 IKEv2 ECDH Public Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP4-10 IKEv2 ECDH Private Key
(read/write/delete)
CSP7-1 DRBG entropy input (read/write/delete)
CSP8-1 DRBG seed (read/write/delete)
CSP8-2 DRBG V (read/write/delete)
CSP8-3 DRBG Key (read/write/delete)
8. Provide SNMPv3 service.
Commands and
configuration data
Status of
commands and
configuration data
CSP9-1 SNMPv3 Authentication Key (read)
CSP9-2 SNMPv3 Encryption Key (read)
CSP7-1 DRBG entropy input (read/write/delete)
CSP8-1 DRBG seed (read/write/delete)
CSP8-2 DRBG V (read/write/delete)
CSP8-3 DRBG Key (read/write/delete)
Level-0,
Level-1
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 34 of 68
6.1.2 Unauthenticated Services
 Cycle the power on the router
 View currently running image version;
 View installed hardware components status and version
 View memory status, packet statistics, interface status, current running image version, current configuration, routing table, active sessions,
temperature and SNMP MIB statistics
6.1.3 Non-Approved Services
The HPE network routers support the following non-approved services:
 Internet Key Exchange (IKE) or Internet Protocol Security (IPsec) with AES-XCBC-MAC, Camellia, DES, Triple-DES, MD5, HMAC-MD5, Diffie-
Hellman (<2048-bits), RSA (< 2048-bits), DSA (< 2048-bits).
 Perform Network Time Protocol (NTP) service.
 Perform Secure Socket Layer (SSL) 3.0 or Transport Layer Security (TLS) 1.0, 1.1, 1.2.
 Perform Secure Shell version 1.x.
 Perform Secure Shell version 2.0 with DES, Triple-DES, MD5, HMAC-MD5, Diffie-Hellman (<2048-bits), RSA (< 2048-bits), DSA (<2048-bits)
 Perform Telnet
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 35 of 68
6.2 Critical Security Parameters
4
Critical security parameter (CSP): security-related information (e.g., secret and private cryptographic keys, and authentication data such as passwords and PINs)
whose disclosure or modification can compromise the security of a cryptographic module.
5
Assumptions, Assertions and Caveats
1. Preferably, the Key / CSP Table should be listed after the Services Table.
2. Each Key(s) / CSP(s) must be mapped to by a service. A Key / CSP cannot exist unless associated with a service.
3. Each Key / CSP should be uniquely identifiable so the entries in the Services Table can easily map to a Key / CSP.
4. The DH key pairs should be 2 entries in the table. One for the public key and one for the private key – since the key lengths are different
 Each public key should be in its own row.
 Each private key should be in its own row.
5. For all RSA keys, state whether it is used for key transport or signature generation/verification.
 Key transport should be in its own row.
 Signature generation/verification should be in its own row.
6. Where possible, group Key / CSP together e.g. Keys associated with a protocol should be grouped together.
KEY / CSP Table Column Definitions
1. Key / CSP #
Unique identifier of CSP
2. Key or CSP Name
Objective of this column is to list the type of key or CSP used by the cryptographic module.
4
FIPS Pub 140-2
5
In Comware, CSPs generated in FIPS mode cannot be used in non-FIPS mode, and vice versa.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 36 of 68
 To avoid confusion wherever possible it is recommended that the name of the key/CSP be consistent with a recognized industry standard such as ISO, IETF or NIST Special
Publication.
3. Key/CSP Type & Algorithm Link
Objective of this column is to provide additional information about the CSP.
 Where applicable this column shall include the type of key/CSP, algorithm(s) (including reference to FIPS or NIST SP).
 The Algorithm link points to the Algorithm in the Algorithm table the Key/CSP uses.
4. Key size
Size of the key used by the CSP.
5. Use
The objective of this column is to provide information on how the key is used during cryptographic module operation.
 This column should contain a short description of the Key/CSP.
 It is important that each CSP is mapped directly from an Approved service that the cryptographic module performs.
 For all RSA keys, this column shall specify whether it is used for key transport or signature generation/verification
6. Generation/Input
The objective of this column is to specify how and when the CSP is generated, derived or enters the module.
 If the CSP is generated or derived, this column shall specify the function or technique responsible.
 If the CSP is entered, the column shall specify if the CSP is entered electronically or manually.
 The column shall specify if it is stored encrypted or in plaintext form.
 If the CSP is ephemeral this column shall specify conditions upon which it is generated (A cryptographic key is called ephemeral if it is generated for each execution of a key
establishment process.).
7. Storage
The objective of this column is to specify where the CSP is stored during cryptographic module operation.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 37 of 68
 The column shall also state the location and type of storage.
 The column shall state if the CSP is persistent, ephemeral or hardcoded.
 The column shall specify if it is stored encrypted or in plaintext form.
 The column shall specify if only a pointer or reference to the CSP is stored or the actual CSP.
8. Output
The objective of this column is to specify if the CSP can be output from the cryptographic module.
 If the CSP can be output, the column shall specify how it can be output.
 If the CSP can be output, the column shall specify if it is encrypted or plaintext form.
9. Zeroization
The objective of this column is to provide details on how the CSP shall be zeroized.
 All possible zeroization techniques for the CSP shall be listed.
Table 6 Critical Security Parameters
#
Key /
CSP Name
Key / CSP Type
Key Size Use
Generation
6
/
Input
Storage Output Zeroization
Algorithm Link
Public key management
CSP1-1 RSA public key
RSA
2048 bits
Identity certificates for the
security appliance itself
and also used in IPsec
and SSH.
Electronically
generated FLASH (cipher
text / AES256)
Plaintext
Using CLI command to
zeroize.
RSA-1
RSA-2
6 6
For all keys marked as “Electronically generated”, the resulting symmetric key or the generated seed to be used in the asymmetric key generation is an unmodified output from the DRBG.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 38 of 68
#
Key /
CSP Name
Key / CSP Type
Key Size Use
Generation
6
/
Input
Storage Output Zeroization
Algorithm Link
RSA-3
RSA-4
CSP1-2 DSA public key
DSA
2048 bits
Identity certificates for the
security appliance itself
and also used in IPsec
and SSH.
Electronically
generated FLASH (cipher
text / AES256)
Plaintext
Using CLI command to
zeroize
DSA-1
DSA-2
DSA-3
DSA-4
CSP1-3 ECDSA public key
ECDSA
NIST P256,
P384, P521
Identity certificates for the
security appliance itself
and also used in IPsec
and SSH.
Electronically
generated FLASH (cipher
text / AES256)
Plaintext
Using CLI command to
zeroize
ECDSA-1
ECDSA-2
ECDSA-3
IPsec
CSP2-1
IPsec
authentication keys
HMAC-SHA1-96
HMAC-SHA-256-
128
HMAC-SHA-384-
192
HMAC-SHA-512-
256
GMAC-128
GMAC-192
HMAC:
160 bits
256 bits
384 bits
512 bits
AES GMAC:
128 bits
Used to authenticate the
IPsec traffic
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
session expires.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 39 of 68
#
Key /
CSP Name
Key / CSP Type
Key Size Use
Generation
6
/
Input
Storage Output Zeroization
Algorithm Link
GMAC-256 192 bits
256 bits
HMAC-1
HMAC-2
HMAC-3
AES-1
AES-2
AES-3
CSP2-2
IPsec encryption
keys
AES
128 bits, 192
bits,
256 bits
Used to encrypt the IPsec
traffic
Electronically
generated as part
of SP800-135
KDF
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
session expires.
AES-1
AES-2
AES-3
CSP2-3
IPsec
authentication keys
HMAC-SHA1-96
HMAC-SHA-256-
128
HMAC-SHA-384-
192
HMAC-SHA-512-
256
GMAC-128
GMAC-192
GMAC-256
HMAC:
160 bits
256 bits
384 bits
512 bits
AES GMAC:
128 bits
192 bits
256 bits
Used to authenticate the
IPsec traffic
Manually entered
by the Crypto-
Officer
FLASH (cipher
text / AES-CTR
256) and RAM
(plain text)
Encrypted
Keys will be zeroized
using CLI commands
“undo sa hex-key
authentication …” and
“ save”,
HMAC-1
HMAC-2
HMAC-3
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 40 of 68
#
Key /
CSP Name
Key / CSP Type
Key Size Use
Generation
6
/
Input
Storage Output Zeroization
Algorithm Link
AES-1
AES-2
AES-3
CSP2-4
IPsec encryption
keys
AES
128 bits, 192
bits,
256 bits
Used to encrypt the IPsec
traffic
Manually entered
by the Crypto-
Officer
FLASH (cipher
text / AES-CTR
256) and RAM
(plain text)
Encrypted
Keys will be zeroized
using CLI commands
“undo sa hex-key
encryption …” and
“ save”,
AES-1
AES-2
AES-3
IKEv1
CSP3-1
IKE pre-shared
keys
Shared Secret
15 ~ 128 bytes
Used for authentication
during IKE
Manually entered
by the Crypto-
Officer
FLASH(cipher
text/ AES-CTR-
256) and RAM
(cipher text/
AES-CTR-256)
Encrypted
Using CLI command to
zeroize
AES-3
CSP3-2
IKE RSA
Authentication
private Key
RSA
2048 bits
private key used for IKE
protocol during the
handshake
Electronically
generated
OR
Externally
generated; input
in ciphertext
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
RSA-1
RSA-3
RSA-4
CSP3-3
IKE DSA
Authentication
private Key
DSA
256 bits
private key used for IKE
protocol during the
handshake
Electronically
generated
OR
Externally
generated; input
in ciphertext
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
DSA-3
DSA-4
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 41 of 68
#
Key /
CSP Name
Key / CSP Type
Key Size Use
Generation
6
/
Input
Storage Output Zeroization
Algorithm Link
CSP3-4
IKE Authentication
key
HMAC-SHA1,
HMAC-SHA256
HMAC-HA384,
HMAC-SHA512
160 bits
256 bits
384 bits,
512 bits
Used to authenticate IKE
negotiations
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
session expires.
HMAC-2
HMAC-3
CSP3-5 IKE Encryption Key
AES 128 bits, 192
bits,
256 bits
Used to encrypt IKE
negotiations
Electronically
generated as part
of SP800-135
KDF
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
session expires.
AES-3
CSP3-6
IKE Diffie-Hellman
Public Key
DH
2048 bits Key agreement for IKE
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text) Plaintext
Automatically when
handshake finishing
CVL-1
CSP3-7
IKE Diffie-Hellman
Private Key
DH DH Group 14:
2048 bits
DH Group 24:
256 bits
Key agreement for IKE
Electronically
generated as part
of SP800-135
KDF
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
CVL-1
IKEv2
CSP4-1
IKEv2 pre-shared
keys
Shared Secret
15 ~ 128 bytes
Used for authentication
during IKEv2
Manually entered
by the Crypto-
Officer
FLASH(cipher
text/ AES-CTR-
256) and RAM
(cipher text/
AES-CTR-256)
Encrypted
Using CLI command to
zeroize
AES-3
CSP4-2
IKEv2 RSA
Authentication
RSA 2048 bits
private key used for
IKEv2 protocol during the
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 42 of 68
#
Key /
CSP Name
Key / CSP Type
Key Size Use
Generation
6
/
Input
Storage Output Zeroization
Algorithm Link
private Key RSA-1
RSA-3
RSA-4
handshake OR
Externally
generated; input
in ciphertext
CSP4-3
IKEv2 DSA
Authentication
private Key
DSA
256 bits
private key used for
IKEv2 protocol during the
handshake
Electronically
generated
OR
Externally
generated; input
in ciphertext
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
DSA-3
DSA-4
CSP4-4
IKEv2 ECDSA
Authentication
private Key
ECDSA
ECDSA:P-256,
P-384, P-521
private key used for
IKEv2 protocol during the
handshake
Electronically
generated
OR
Externally
generated; input
in ciphertext
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
ECDSA-2
ECDSA-3
CSP4-5
IKEv2
Authentication key
HMAC-SHA1,
HMAC-SHA256
HMAC-HA384,
HMAC-SHA512
160 bits
256 bits
384 bits,
512 bits
Used to authenticate
IKEv2 negotiations
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
session expires.
HMAC-2
HMAC-3
CSP4-6
IKEv2 Encryption
Key
AES 128 bits, 192
bits,
256 bits
Used to encrypt IKEv2
negotiations
Electronically
generated as part
of SP800-135
KDF
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
session expires.
AES-3
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 43 of 68
#
Key /
CSP Name
Key / CSP Type
Key Size Use
Generation
6
/
Input
Storage Output Zeroization
Algorithm Link
CSP4-7
IKEv2 Diffie-
Hellman Public
Key
DH
2048 bits Key agreement for IKEv2
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
CVL-1
CSP4-8
IKEv2 Diffie-
Hellman Private
Key
DH DH Group 14:
2048 bits
DH Group 24:
256 bits
Key agreement for IKEv2
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
CVL-1
CSP4-9
IKEv2 ECDH
Public Key
ECDH
P-256, P-384 Key agreement for IKEv2
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
CVL-2
CSP4-10
IKEv2 ECDH
Private Key
ECDH
P-256: 256 bits
P-384: 384 bits
Key agreement for IKEv2
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text)
No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
CVL-2
SSH
CSP5-1
SSH RSA
Private key
RSA
2048 bits
private key used for SSH
protocol
Electronically
generated
OR
Externally
generated; input
in ciphertext
RAM(plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
RSA-1
RSA-3
RSA-4
CSP5-2 SSH ECDSA ECDSA P-256, P-384 private key used for SSH Electronically RAM(plain text) No Automatically when
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 44 of 68
#
Key /
CSP Name
Key / CSP Type
Key Size Use
Generation
6
/
Input
Storage Output Zeroization
Algorithm Link
Private key
ECDSA-3
protocol generated
OR
Externally
generated; input
in ciphertext
handshake finishing
CSP5-3
SSH Diffie-Hellman
Public Key
DH
2048 bits
Public key agreement for
SSH sessions.
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
CVL-1
CSP5-4
SSH Diffie-Hellman
Private Key
DH
2048 bits
Private key agreement for
SSH sessions.
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
CVL-1
CSP5-5
SSH ECDH Public
Key
ECDH
P-256, P-384
Public key agreement for
SSH sessions.
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
CVL-2
CSP5-6
SSH ECDH Private
Key
ECDH
P-256, P-384
Private key agreement for
SSH sessions.
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text)
No
Automatically when
handshake finishing
CVL-2
CSP5-7
SSH Session
encryption Key
AES
128 bits,
256 bits
SSH session symmetric
key
Electronically
generated as part
of SP800-135
KDF
RAM (plain text)
No
Automatically when SSH
session terminated
AES-3
CSP5-8
SSH Session
authentication Key
HMAC 160 bits
256 bits
512 bits
SSH session
authentication key
Electronically
generated
RAM (plain text) No
Automatically when SSH
session terminated
HMAC-2
HMAC-3
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 45 of 68
#
Key /
CSP Name
Key / CSP Type
Key Size Use
Generation
6
/
Input
Storage Output Zeroization
Algorithm Link
Authentication
CSP6-1 User Passwords
Secret
15 ~ 63 bytes
Used to authenticate the
administrator login.
Manually entered
by the Crypto-
Officer
FLASH (cipher
text / AES256)
Encrypted
Using CLI command to
zeroize
AES-3
CSP6-2 Super password
Secret
15 ~ 63 bytes
Used to authenticate the
user role.
Manually entered
by the Crypto-
Officer
FLASH (cipher
text / AES256)
Encrypted
Using CLI command to
zeroize
AES-3
CSP6-3
RADIUS shared
secret keys
Shared Secret
15 ~ 64 bytes
Used for authenticating
the RADIUS server to the
security appliance and
vice versa.
Manually entered
by the Crypto-
Officer
FLASH (cipher
text / AES256)
Encrypted
Using CLI command to
zeroize
AES-3
CSP6-4
TACACS+ shared
secret keys
Shared Secret
15~255 bytes
Used for authenticating
the TACACS+ server to
the security appliance
and vice versa.
Manually entered
by the Crypto-
Officer
FLASH (cipher
text / AES256)
Encrypted
Using CLI command to
zeroize
AES-3
Entropy
CSP7-1
DRBG entropy
input
SP 800-90A
CTR_DRBG
256 bits
Entropy source used to
construct seed
Electronically
generated
RAM
(plaintext)
No
Resetting or rebooting
the security appliance
DRBG-1
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 46 of 68
#
Key /
CSP Name
Key / CSP Type
Key Size Use
Generation
6
/
Input
Storage Output Zeroization
Algorithm Link
Random Bits Generation
CSP8-1 DRBG seed
SP 800-90A
CTR_DRBG 384 bits
Input to the DRBG that
determines the internal
state of the DRBG
Electronically
generated
RAM
(plaintext)
Never exits the
module
Resetting or rebooting
the security appliance
DRBG-1
CSP8-2 DRBG V
SP 800-90A
CTR_DRBG
128 bits
Generated by entropy
source via the
CTR_DRBG derivation
function. It is stored in
DRAM with plaintext form
Electronically
generated
RAM
(plaintext)
Never exits the
module
Resetting or rebooting
the security appliance
DRBG-1
CSP8-3 DRBG Key
SP 800-90A
CTR_DRBG
256 bits
AES key used for SP
800-90A CTR_DRBG
Electronically
generated
RAM (plaintext)
Never exits the
module
Resetting or rebooting
the security appliance
DRBG-1
SNMPv3
CSP9-1
SNMPv3
Authentication Key
HMAC-SHA1
160 bits
Used to verify SNMPv3
packet.
Manually entered
by the Crypto-
Officer
OR
Electronically
derived from
SP800-135 KDF
FLASH (cipher
text / AES256)
RAM (plain text)
Encrypted
Using CLI command to
zeroize
HMAC-3
CSP9-2 SNMPv3 AES 128 bits Used to encrypt SNMPv3 Manually entered FLASH (cipher Encrypted Using CLI command to
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 47 of 68
#
Key /
CSP Name
Key / CSP Type
Key Size Use
Generation
6
/
Input
Storage Output Zeroization
Algorithm Link
Encryption Key
AES-3
packet. by the Crypto-
Officer
text / AES256)
RAM (plain text)
zeroize
System KEK
CSP10-1 Key encrypting key
AES
256 bits
Used to encrypt all
private key, user
password, and pre-
shared key stored on
internal storage. The
KEK is generated using
random bytes
Electronically
generated
RAM
(plain text)
No
Zeroized when Resetting
or rebooting the security
appliance
AES-1
AES-2
AES-3
System Firmware
CSP11-1
Firmware
Signature
RSA
2048 bits
Factory signature used to
verify Comware 7
firmware.
Generated by
HPE Comware 7
Build Team
FLASH (binary
images)
Binary image
Upon deletion of binary
image.
RSA-4
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 48 of 68
6.3 Approved Algorithms
Assumptions, Assertions and Caveats
1. Each instantiation of the algorithm should be in a separate table
 e.g. kernel, firmware, accelerators
 e.g. chassis / controller
2. Each instantiation of the algorithm should be uniquely identifiable so the Key / CSP can easily map to an algorithm.
3. Include a reference to the FIPS 140-2 approved standard for each algorithm. One example is to use a footnote.
4. The ECB mode is required for all other AES modes. The ECB mode should be listed as not used by the module if ECB is only used to support the other modes. If the ECB mode is
used by one or more services, it should be listed as available. Although ECB is the basis for all other AES modes, it is latent functionality if there is no service that uses it.
5. Each instantiation of the algorithm must map to the service that uses it.
6. To expedite the review process, each instantiation of the algorithm should have a hyperlink to the CAVP page that contains the certification listing.
7. It is important to identify which algorithms are used by the module and which are not. All functionality listed on the CAVP certificate should be detailed somewhere in the tables,
footnotes, or text of the Security Policy. If all of the functionality is used by the module, then all algorithm functionality belongs in the tables. If some functionality is not used by
the module, then the author should determine the best to convey that to the reader. (The Tables use footnotes. But there are other ways to convey this information.)
Algorithm Table Column Definitions
1. Algorithm #
Unique identifier of the algorithm. Each instantiation should be uniquely identified.
2. CAVP Certificate
Objective of this column is identify the CAVP certificate.
 The certificate number should be listed.
 A hyperlink should be create to the CAVP website to the certificate number.
3. Algorithm
Objective of this column is identify the Algorithm in use.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 49 of 68
 The algorithm name should be consistent with the names list on the Cryptographic Algorithm Validation Program (CAVP) website.
 The acronym may be used instead of the full name.
 Include a reference to the FIPS 140-2 approved standard for each algorithm.
4. Mode / Method
Objective of this column is identify the Mode / Method used by the algorithm.
5. Key Lengths, Curves or Moduli
Objective of this column is identify the Key Lengths, Curves or Moduli used by the algorithm.
6. Use
Objective of this column is identify the use of the algorithm.
7. Service that uses Algorithm
Objective of this column is identify the services that use the algorithm.
 A cross reference should be made to the unique identifier in a services table
 The cross reference should contain a hyperlink to the entry in a services table.
 The relationship of algorithm to service maybe one-to-one, one-to-many, or many-to-many.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 50 of 68
Table 7 Comware V7 Kernel – Approved Algorithms
#
CAVP
Certificate
Algorithm Mode/ Method
Key Lengths,
Curves or Moduli
Use
Service that uses
Algorithm
AES-1 4096 AES
7 ECB
8
, CBC
9
, CTR, GCM
10
,
GMAC
128, 192, 256
Kernel – Data
Encryption/ Decryption
Crypto Officer Services
(7, 21, 24)
User Services
(7)
HMAC-1 2676 HMAC
11
HMAC SHA-1
12
160 Kernel - Message
Authentication
Crypto Officer Services
(7, 21, 24)
User Services
(7)
SHS-1 3372
SHS
13
SHA-1
12
Kernel – Message
Digest
Crypto Officer Services
(7, 21, 24)
User Services
(7)
TDES-1
14
2239 Triple-DES
15
TECB
16
, TCBC 192 Self-tests
Crypto Officer Services
(24)
7
FIPS 197
8
Not used by the module
9
SP 800-38A
10
The module's AES-GCM implementation conforms to IG A.5 scenario #1 following RFC 6071 for IPsec and RFC 5288 for TLS. The module uses a 96-bit IV, which is comprised of a 4 byte salt
unique to the crypto session and 8 byte monotonically increasing counter. The module generates new AES-GCM keys if the module loses power.
11
FIPS 198-1
12
Although this implementation supports additional modes, only the modes listed are utilized.
13
FIPS 180-4
14
Although the certification contains Triple-DES, Triple-DES is used only for self-tests in the approved mode.
15
SP 800-67rev1
16
Not used by the module
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 51 of 68
#
CAVP
Certificate
Algorithm Mode/ Method
Key Lengths,
Curves or Moduli
Use
Service that uses
Algorithm
User Services
(None)
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 52 of 68
Table 8 Comware V7 HW Accelerators – Approved Algorithms
#
CAVP
Certificate
Algorithm Mode/ Method
Key Lengths or
Curves
Use
Service that uses
Algorithm
AES-2 4094 AES
17 ECB
18
, CBC, CTR, GCM
19
,
GMAC
128, 192, 256
Data Encryption/
Decryption
Crypto Officer
Services
(5, 6, 7, 8, 13, 14, 15,
16, 24)
User Services
5, 6, 7, 8
HMAC-2 2674
HMAC
20 HMAC SHA-1, HMAC SHA-
224
21
, HMAC SHA-256, HMAC
SHA-384, HMAC SHA-512
160, 256, 384,
512
Message
Authentication
Crypto Officer
Services
(5, 6, 7, 8, 13, 14, 15,
16, 24)
User Services
5, , 6, 7, 8
SHS-2 3370
SHS
22
SHA-1, SHA-256,
SHA-384, SHA-512
Message Digest
Crypto Officer
Services
(5, 6, 7, 8, 13, 14, 15,
16, 24)
User Services
5, 6, 7, 8
17
FIPS 197
18
Not used by the module
19
SP 800-38A, SP 800-38D
The module's AES-GCM implementation conforms to IG A.5 scenario #1 following RFC 6071 for IPsec and RFC 5288 for TLS. The module uses a 96-bit IV, which is comprised of a 4 byte salt
unique to the crypto session and 8 byte monotonically increasing counter. The module generates new AES-GCM keys if the module loses power.
20
FIPS 198-1
21
Not used by the module
22
FIPS 180-4
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 53 of 68
#
CAVP
Certificate
Algorithm Mode/ Method
Key Lengths or
Curves
Use
Service that uses
Algorithm
TDES-2
23
2237 Triple-DES
24
TECB
25
, TCBC 192 Self-tests
Crypto Officer
Services
(24)
User Services
(none)
Table 9 Comware V7 HW Accelerators - Allowed Algorithms
Algorithm Caveat Use Service that uses
Algorithm
None
Crypto Officer
Services
(none)
User Services
(none)
23
Although the certification contains Triple-DES, Triple-DES is used only for self-tests in the approved mode.
24
SP 800-67rev1
25
Not used by the module
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 54 of 68
Table 10 Comware V7 Firmware – Approved Algorithms
#
CAVP
Certificate
Algorithm Mode/ Method
Key Lengths or
Curves
Use
Service that uses
Algorithm
AES-3 4091 AES
26 ECB
27
, CBC, CTR, GCM
28
,
GMAC, KW
29 128, 192, 256
Data Encryption/
Decryption
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7, 8, 11, 12, 13, 21,
22, 23, 24)
User Services
(5, 6, 7, 8)
CVL-1
30
908
CVL
31
IKEv1, IKEv2
TLS 1.0/1.1
32
SSH, SNMPv3
KDFs
Key Derivation
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7, 8, 24)
User Services
(5, 6, 7, 8)
DRBG-1 1229 DRBG
33
CTR (AES-256)
Deterministic Random
Bit Generation
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7, 8, 13, 24)
26
FIPS 197, SP 800-38A, SP 800-38D
27
Not used by the module
28
The module's AES-GCM implementation conforms to IG A.5 scenario #1 following RFC 6071 for IPsec and RFC 5288 for TLS. The module uses a 96-bit IV, which is comprised of a 4 byte salt
unique to the crypto session and 8 byte monotonically increasing counter. The module generates new AES-GCM keys if the module loses power.
29
Not used by the module
30
Component Validation: the protocols covered under this certificate have not been reviewed or tested by the CAVP or CMVP
31
SP 800-135rev1
32
Although the certification contains TLS, it is not used in the approved mode in this version of Comware.
33
SP 800-90A
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 55 of 68
#
CAVP
Certificate
Algorithm Mode/ Method
Key Lengths or
Curves
Use
Service that uses
Algorithm
User Services
(5, 6, 7, 8)
DSA-1
1112 DSA
34
SHA-256, SHA-384, SHA-512 (2048,256) Domain Parameter
Generation
Crypto Officer Services
(13, 24)
User Services
(none)
DSA-2 (2048,256) Key Pair Generation
Crypto Officer Services
(13, 24)
User Services
(none)
DSA-3
SHA-224, SHA-256
SHA-384, SHA-512
(2048,256) Digital Signature
Generation
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7, 24)
User Services
(5, 6, 7)
DSA-4
SHA-1, SHA-224, SHA-256
SHA-384, SHA-512
(1024,160)
(2048,256)
Digital Signature
Verification
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7, 24)
User Services
(5, 6, 7)
CVL-2 907
CVL –EC Diffie-
Hellman
Primitive
35
P-224
36
, P-256,
P-384, P-521
36
Shared Secret for Key
Agreement Scheme
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7)
34
FIPS 186-4
35
SP 800-56A, Section 5.7.1.2: ECC CDH Primitive
36
Mode not used by module
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 56 of 68
#
CAVP
Certificate
Algorithm Mode/ Method
Key Lengths or
Curves
Use
Service that uses
Algorithm
User Services
(5, 6, 7)
ECDSA-1
925 ECDSA
37
P-224, P-256,
P-384, P-521
Key Pair Generation
Crypto Officer Services
(13, 24)
User Services
(none)
ECDSA-2
SHA-224, SHA-256,
SHA-384, SHA-512
P-224, P-256,
P-384, P-521
Digital Signature
Generation
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7, 24)
User Services
5, 6, 7
ECDSA-3
SHA-1, SHA-224, SHA-256,
SHA-384, SHA-512
P-192
38
, P-224, P-
256,
P-384, P-521
Digital Signature
Verification
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7, 24)
User Services
5, 6, 7
HMAC-3 2671 HMAC
39
HMAC SHA-1, HMAC SHA-
224
40
, HMAC SHA-256, HMAC
SHA-384, HMAC SHA-512
160, 256, 384, 512 Message Authentication
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7, 8, 24)
User Services
(5, 6, 7, 8)
37
FIPS 186-4
38
Not used in the approved mode.
39
FIPS 198-1
40
Mode not used by module.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 57 of 68
#
CAVP
Certificate
Algorithm Mode/ Method
Key Lengths or
Curves
Use
Service that uses
Algorithm
RSA-1
2215
RSA
41 SHA-1
PKCS1 v.1.5
2048 Digital Signature
Verification
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7)
User Services
5, 6, 7
RSA-2
RSA
42
Random Public Exponent e 2048 Key Pair Generation
Crypto Officer Services
(13, 24)
User Services
(none)
RSA-3
SHA-224, SHA-256,
SHA-384, SHA-512
PKCS1 v.1.5
2048 Digital Signature
Generation
Crypto Officer Services
(7, 24)
User Services
(7)
RSA-4
SHA-1, SHA-224, SHA-256,
SHA-384, SHA-512
PKCS1 v1.5
2048 Digital Signature
Verification
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7, 24, 34)
User Services
(5, 6, 7)
SHS-3 3367
SHS
43
SHA-1, SHA-224, SHA-256,
SHA-384, SHA-512
Message Digest
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7, 8, 11, 12, 21, 22,
24)
User Services
41
FIPS 186-2
42
FIPS 186-4
43
FIPS 180-4
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 58 of 68
#
CAVP
Certificate
Algorithm Mode/ Method
Key Lengths or
Curves
Use
Service that uses
Algorithm
(5, 6, 7, 8)
TDES-3
44
2234 Triple-DES
45
TECB, TCBC 192 Self-tests
Crypto Officer Services
(24)
User Services
none
44
Although the certification contains Triple DES, it is not used in this version of Comware
45
SP 800-67rev1
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 59 of 68
6.4 Allowed Algorithms
Table 11 Comware V7 Firmware - Allowed Algorithms
Algorithm Caveat Use Service that uses
Algorithm
Diffie-Hellman Provides 112 bits of encryption strength. Key establishment
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7)
User Services
(5, 6, 7)
Elliptic Curve Diffie-Hellman
Supported curves: P-256 and
P-384
Provides 128 and 192-bits of encryption
strength.
Key establishment
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7)
User Services
(5, 6, 7)
HMAC-SHA1-96
Hash Message Authentication Code
truncated to 96-bits.
SSH and IPsec
Authentication
Crypto Officer Services
(5, 6, 7)
User Services
(5, 6, 7)
NDRNG
46 A minimum of 256-bits of entropy is
obtained before generating keys.
Seeding for the DRBG
Crypto Officer Services
(none)
User Services
(none)
46
This implementation satisfies Scenario 1(a) of IG 7.14
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 60 of 68
6.5 Non-Approved Algorithms
Table 12 Non-Approved Algorithms47
Algorithm Use Service that uses
Algorithm
AES (non-compliant) Encryption / Decryption IKEv2, IPSEC
Camellia Encryption / Decryption IKEv2, IPSEC, SSHv2
DES Encryption / Decryption IKEv1/v2, IPSEC,
SSHv1/v2, SSL
Diffie-Hellman Key Establishment - Non-compliant
less than 112 bits of encryption
strength
IKEv1/v2, IPSEC, SSHv2,
SSL, TLS
DSA (FIPS 186-2) Digital Signature Generation IKEv1/v2, IPSEC, SSHv2
DSA (FIPS 186-4) Digital Signature Generation (security
strength less than 112 bits)
IKEv1/v2, IPSEC, SSHv2
ECDSA (FIPS 186-2) Digital Signature Generation IKEv1/v2, IPSEC, SSHv2,
SSL, TLS
ECDSA (FIPS 186-4) Digital Signature Generation (security
strength less than 112 bits)
IKEv1/v2, IPSEC, SSHv2,
SSL, TLS
HMAC-MD5 Keyed Hash IKEv1/v2, IPSEC, SSHv2,
SSL, TLS
47
Please see NIST document SP800-131Arev1 for guidance regarding the use of non FIPS-approved algorithms
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 61 of 68
MD5 Hashing IKEv1/v2, IPSEC, SSHv2,
SSL, TLS
RC2 Encryption / Decryption SSL
RC4 Encryption / Decryption SSL
RNG (ANSI x9.31) Random Number Generation Self-test
RSA (FIPS 186-2) Asymmetric Key Generation IKEv1/v2, IPSEC,
SSHv1/v2, SSL, TLS
RSA Key Wrapping – non-compliant less
than 112 bits of encryption strength
SSHv1, SSL, TLS
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 62 of 68
7 Self-Tests
HPE Networking devices include an array of self-tests that are run during startup and during
operations to prevent any secure data from being released and to insure all components are
functioning correctly.
7.1 Power-On Self-Tests
The following table lists the power-on self-tests implemented by the routers. The routers
perform all power-on self-tests automatically at boot. All power-on self-tests must be passed
before any role can perform services. The power-on self-tests are performed prior to the
initialization of the forwarding function, which prevents the security appliance from passing any
data during a power-on self-test failure.
Table 13 Power-On Self-Tests
Implementation Tests Performed
Security Appliance Software Software/firmware Test (non-Approved RSA 2048 with
SHA-256 which acts as a 256 bit EDC)
DSA signature and verification PWCT
ECDSA signature and verification PWCT
ECDH KAT
Kernel Triple-DES encryption and Triple-DES decryption
KAT
Triple-DES encryption and Triple-DES decryption KAT
RSA signature KAT and verification KAT
RSA signature and verification PWCT
RSA encryption and decryption PWCT
Kernel AES encrypt KAT and AES decrypt KAT
AES encrypt KAT and AES decrypt KAT
Kernel AES-GCM encrypt KAT and AES-GCM decrypt
KAT
AES-GCM encrypt KAT and AES-GCM decrypt KAT
Kernel GMAC KAT
Kernel SHA KATs (SHA-1, SHA-256, SHA-384, and
SHA-512)
SHA KATs (SHA-1, SHA-224, SHA-256, SHA-384, and
SHA-512)
Kernel HMAC KATs (SHA-1, SHA-256, SHA-384, and
SHA-512)
HMAC KATs (SHA-1, SHA-224, SHA-256, SHA-384, and
SHA-512)
SP800-90a CTR_DRBG KATs (Instantiate KAT,
Generate KAT and Reseed KAT)
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 63 of 68
7.2 Conditional Self-Tests
The following table lists the conditional self-tests implemented by the routers. Conditional self-
tests run when a router generates an ECDSA or RSA key pair and when it generates a random
number.
Table 14 Conditional Self-Tests
Implementation Tests Performed
Security Appliance Software
Pairwise consistency test for RSA
Pairwise consistency test for DSA
Pairwise consistency test for ECDSA
Continuous Random Number Generator Test for the FIPS-
approved SP800-90a CTR_DRBG
SP800-90A Section 11.3 Health Tests for CTR_DRBG
(Instantiate, Generate and Reseed).
Continuous Random Number Generator Test for entropy
source (NDRNG)
Firmware Load Test (RSA PKCS#1 v1.5 2048 bits with
SHA-256)
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 64 of 68
8 Delivery and Operation
8.1 Secure Delivery
To ensure no one has tampered with the goods during delivery, inspect the Networking router
physical package and check as follows:
1. Outer Package Inspection
1) Check that the outer carton is in good condition.
2) Check the package for a HPE Quality Seal or IPQC Seal, and ensure that it is
intact.
3) Check that the IPQC seal on the plastic bag inside the carton is intact.
4) If any check failed, the goods shall be treated as dead-on-arrival (DOA) goods.
2. Packing List Verification
Check against the packing list for discrepancy in material type and quantity. If any
discrepancy found, the goods shall be treated as DOA goods.
3. External Visual Inspection
Inspect the cabinet or chassis for any defects, loose connections, damages, and
illegible marks. If any surface defect or material shortage found, the goods shall be
treated as DOA goods.
4. Confirm Software/firmware
1) Version verification
To verify the software version, start the appliance, view the self-test result
during startup, and use the display version command to check that the software
version.
 For the MSR3024, “HPE Comware Software, Version 7.1.045, Release
R0305P08” indicates it is a FIPS 140-2 and CC certification version.
If software loading failed or the version information is incorrect, please contact
HPE for support.
2) RSA with SHA-256 verification
To verify that software/firmware has not been tampered, run SHA Hash
command on the appliance. If the hash value is different from release notes of
this software, contact HPE for support. To get release notes, please access
HPE website.
5. DOA (Dead on Arrival)
If the package is damaged, any label/seal is incorrect or tampered, stop
unpacking the goods, retain the package, and report to HPE for further
investigation. The damaged goods will be replaced if necessary.
8.2 Secure Operation
The rules for securely operating an HPE Networking router in FIPS mode are:
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 65 of 68
1. Install and connect the device according to the installation and configuration guides.
2. Start the device, and enter the configuration interface.
3. Check and configure the clock.
4. By default, the device does not run in FIPS mode. Enable the device to work in FIPS
mode using the fips mode enable command in system view. This will allow the router
to internally enforce FIPS-compliance behavior, such as run power-up self-test and
conditional self-test.
5. Set up username/password for crypto officer role. The password must comprise no less
than 15 characters and must contain uppercase and lowercase letters, digits, and
special characters.
6. Save the configurations and re-start the device.
The device works in FIPS mode after restarting:
1. Configure the security appliance to use SSHv2.
An operator can determine whether a router is in FIPS mode with the command display fips
status. When in FIPS mode:
1. The FTP/TFTP server is disabled.
2. The Telnet server is disabled.
3. The web server is disabled.
4. SNMP v1 and SNMP v2c are disabled. Only SNMP v3 is available.
5. The SSH server does not support SSHv1 clients
6. Generated RSA key pairs have a modulus length 2048 bits.
7. Generated ECDSA key pairs with curves P-256, P-384 and P-521.
8. SSHv2, SNMPv3, IPsec do not support Non-FIPS approved cryptographic algorithms.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 66 of 68
9 Physical Security Mechanism
The HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series conforms to the Security Level 1 requirements
for physical security. The hardware portion of the cryptographic module is a production grade
component. All internal hardware, firmware, and cryptographic data are protected by the
enclosure of the module, which makes up its physical cryptographic boundary. The
cryptographic module must be used in a production grade enclosure.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 67 of 68
10 Mitigation of Other Attacks
The Security appliances do not claim to mitigate any attacks in a FIPS approved mode of
operation.
FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy for HPE FlexNetwork MSR3024 Router Series
Page 68 of 68
11 Documentation References
11.1 Obtaining documentation
You can access the HPE Networking products page: http://h17007.www1.hp.com/us/en/ , where
you can obtain the up-to-date documents of HPE Routers and Switches, such as datasheet,
installation manual, configuration guide, command reference, and so on.
11.2 Technical support
For technical or sales related question please refer to the contacts list on the HPE website:
http://www.HP.com.
The actual support website is:
http://www8.hp.com/us/en/support-drivers.html